18 Min to Read

10 Best Homeowners Insurance Companies of 2022

PropertyNest has done research on the best homeowners insurance companies. Learn how they compare, & which one is right for your home. Discover how much it costs & what it covers.
SF-usa-suburbs.jpg

Even if you have homeowners insurance because your mortgage lender might have required you to get it, it doesn't mean that your home and all your possessions are properly protected.

Not all home insurance policies and companies are created equal. Your needs as a homeowner can vary greatly from even your neighbor.

That's why the right homeowners insurance gives you peace of mind.

It provides financial relief if a covered event does damage to your home, property, or personal belongings.

PropertyNest compared and rated the best homeowners insurance companies to find the very best home insurance providers of 2022 in the country, no matter which state you live in.

While smaller local insurance companies might be able to understand and predict the nuanced requirements for your home's region or area, the larger and older national firms often can offer more coverage options, discounts, experience, better technology, as well as greater financial health.

The following are the best home insurance companies PropertyNest found for different types needs, according to category.

Best Homeowners Insurance Companies of 2022

  • Allstate: Homeowners Insurance with the Most Policy Discounts
  • Lemonade: Best Online Home Insurance Company
  • Liberty Mutual: Cheapest Homeowners Insurance
  • Nationwide: Best Homeowners Insurance for Exclusive Features
  • Chubb: Best Insurance Coverage for High-Value Properties
  • Amica: Best Home Insurance for Handling Claims
  • State Farm: Best Homeowners Insurance for Dwelling Coverage
  • Farmers: Best Home Insurance for Its Extensive Agent Network
  • Erie: Best Policy That Pays the Full Cost of Your Home
  • Progressive: Best Homeowners Insurance for Tailored Plans

Allstate: Home Insurance with the Most Policy Discounts

allstate-homeowners-insurance.jpg
Editors star rating review
Editor's Rating (5 Stars out of 5)

Allstate is a well-recognized name when it comes to insurance nationwide and is generally thought of as a company that offers flexible coverage that fits to the needs of the average homeowner.

It's also a great choice for homeowners looking for discount opportunities as well as those looking for an easy-to-navigate system.

This is important when it comes to filing insurance claims, which can be an arduous and frustrating task with the wrong choice of insurance carrier.

One of the drawbacks can be that coverage and payouts may be restrictive or capped.

Allstate Home Insurance Coverage That Stands Out

Optional add-ons not typical of insurance companies.

  • Yard and garden repairs, including trees and landscaping.
  • Recovery of personal electronic data like photos or videos.
  • Guest medical coverage, also known as no-fault coverage.

What Makes Allstate Unique?

While most insurance companies do offer discounts that usually come with bundling coverage, Allstate gives more opportunities with a wide range of unusual discounts not typically seen in the industry.

Allstate also offers a very user-friendly website that's easy for customers to navigate.

Prospective customers can easily get a free quote online and policyholders have access to digital tools for filing claims.

Another area where Allstate stands out is with customer reviews and ratings, which tend to be higher than average and usually beating out a lot of other national companies.

Read a full Allstate homeowners insurance review.

Allstate Homeowners Insurance Discounts

  • Bundling. If you bundle your home and auto policies with Allstate, you can save up to 25%.
  • Claim-free discount. If you haven’t filed a recent claim, you can save up to 20%.
  • Easy Pay Plan. Auto-pay to pay your premium directly from your bank account will lead to a discount.
  • Home Buyer Discount. You get a new home discount if you buy a newly constructed house.
  • Safe Home Discount. You get an insurance discount if you have safety features such as cameras, additional locks on your doors, and a security system.
  • Welcome Discount. Becoming a new policyholder will get you a discount.
  • 55 and Retired Discount. You'll get a home insurance discount if you are older and do not go to your office.

Allstate Homeowners Insurance Pros & Cons

Pros
  • Easy-to-use website.
  • The optional Rate Guard feature locks in your premium.
  • HostAdvantage for home-sharing or renting.
  • Easy to bundle policies, including life insurance.
Cons
  • Slightly below-average claims.
  • Personal property is lower than average and not up to the level that you would expect from a top leader.  
  • Policy features are limited.
  • Rather than covering your total loss, coverage is capped at a set percentage of the dwelling coverage.
How is Allstate Homeowners Insurance Rated?
J.D. Power (out of 1,000)815
A.M. Best - Financial Strength RatingA+
NAIC Complaint Index2.05
BBBA-

Lemonade: Best Online-Only Home Insurance Company

lemonade-homeowners-insurance.jpg
Editors star rating review
Editor's Rating (4.5 Stars out of 5)

Lemonade is a great choice for home insurance because of its simplicity.

It’s an online-only insurance company that uses artificial intelligence to secure low home insurance rates for prospective policyholders.

Lemonade operates only through its website and mobile app. Both online platforms are simple and easy to use.

Anything you need can be done from the app or website, such as signing up, filing a claim, adjusting your coverage, and canceling your policy.

Homeowners can get paid for a claim in just minutes from the comfort of their homes. The response time is around three minutes and that’s without ever speaking to a person.

Traditional insurance companies often take months to pay a claim.

It's important to note that while Lemonade is continuing to expand its coverage territory, home insurance is not offered in all 50 states.

Homeowners insurance is only offered in the following states and territories: Arizona, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Missouri, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Texas, Virginia, Washington, D.C., and Wisconsin. 

Lemonade Home Insurance Coverage

  • Covers personal property stored in a self-storage unit up to $1,000, in most cases.
  • A pet healthy policy for as little as $10 per month covers your pet if it gets sick or is in an accident.
  • The policy covers treatments, medical bills, medication, and more, which helps you save a lot of money.

What Makes Lemonade Insurance Unique?

Lemonade is very different from other insurance companies in how they make their money.

Because traditional insurance companies take home a bigger profit if you don't file claims (or your claims are denied), this can lead to a conflict of interest.

So, instead of profiting from unclaimed premiums, Lemonade takes a flat fee and donates whatever may be left, after paying claims and expenses, to charities (the Lemonade Giveback).

Read the Lemonade home insurance review.

Lemonade Homeowners Insurance Pros & Cons

Pros
  • Fast quotes in minutes.
  • The company gives back to charitable donations.
  • Flat fee on low monthly premiums.
  • Generally, low rates with good coverage.
Cons
  • Only available online.
  • Not available in all 50 states.
  • Offers few discounts.
  • Doesn't currently offer coverage for high-value properties
How is Lemonade Homeowners Insurance Rated?
J.D. Power (out of 1,000)870
BBBB+
NAIC Complaint Index1.94

Liberty Mutual: Cheapest Homeowners Insurance

Liberty Mutual home insurance
Editors star rating review
Editor's Rating (4.5 Stars out of 5)

Liberty Mutual has been in business for more than 110 years and offers exceptional products like auto, renters, and home and business insurance.

Its homeowners insurance policy stands out among competitors for its relatively affordable prices.

On average, Liberty Mutual costs $1,230 per year or $102 per month for $250,000 in dwelling coverage.

In comparison, the national average for homeowners insurance costs $1,390 per year or $116 per month.

This means Liberty Mutual beat the US average.

In addition, Liberty Mutual is the cheapest insurer overall in comparison to each insurance company we reviewed.

Coverage That Stands Out

Liberty offers a replacement cost as an add-on. If you need to repair or replace your personal belongings after a covered peril, you’ll be reimbursed for the full cost of your items using today’s prices rather than the depreciated value.

Offers six safety discounts.

You can purchase coverage for as little as $5,000, making it a great option for young renters or those who live in small apartments such as a studio.

Blanket jewelry is one of the best in the industry. It replaces your jewelry that is stolen or lost without a deductible and an appraisal.

Liberty’s app has a variety of useful digital resources.

For example, the app allows you to quickly create a home inventory of your personal belongings if a covered peril damages or destroys them.

The inventory is useful for the insurer, as it will know exactly what to reimburse, and by how much.

What Makes Liberty Mutual Unique?

Liberty Mutual’s online quote tool is very clean and intuitive. Its website is streamlined and its app is a game-changer as it allows you to sign documents electronically.

In addition, Liberty Mutual is financially stable. As such, it can reimburse a claim on time even if a natural disaster strikes an area and results in a large number of simultaneous claims.

Read a full Liberty Mutual home insurance review.

Liberty Mutual Homeowners Insurance Pros & Cons

Pros
  • Best for homeowners looking for cheap rates.
  • Live chat to help prospective policyholders during the quote process.
  • 10% discount for shopping online.
  • Inflation protection adjusts coverage each year to account for inflation.
  • Claims can be made by video call.
  • A variety of discounts can help you save.
  • Easy to use website and innovative app.
Cons
  • Fewer add-ons than many other insurers.
  • Large number of claims complaints.
  • Low overall customer satisfaction ranking.
  • Coverage and discounts vary by state.
  • No liability coverage included for some dog breeds.
  • NAIC customer complaints are worse than the median industry score.
  • Owning old home or having history of making claims may prevent you from using discounts to reduce your premiums.
How is Liberty Mutual Homeowners Insurance Rated?
J.D. Power (out of 1,000)805
A.M. Best - Financial Strength RatingA
BBBA+
NAIC Complaint Index2.37

Nationwide: Best Homeowners Insurance for Exclusive Features

nationwide-homeowners-insurance.jpg
Editors star rating review
Editor's Rating (4 Stars out of 5)

Nationwide features standard coverage. But the company also has a type of insurance that other insurers often charge extra for.

If you have a covered loss and need to update your home to current building codes during repairs or renos, Nationwide will cover you with a limit of up to 10% of your standard dwelling coverage.

If it costs more than expected to rebuild your home after a covered disaster, Nationwide will raise your dwelling coverage up to 20% above your policy limit.

Nationwide Home Insurance Coverage That Stands Out

  • Home renovation credit. If you update your plumbing, electrical systems, and HVAC, you’ll get a discount.
  • Roof replacement pays to rebuild your roof with stronger materials if it’s damaged for a covered reason.
  • Nationwide will pay to replace brand new possessions in full or restore damaged belongings, which is not usually customary.

What Makes Nationwide Insurance Unique?

As the title suggests, Nationwide has all kinds of special add-ons, so any homeowner can best customize their coverage to fit their needs.

What's more is that Nationwide offers plenty of opportunities to qualify for discounts and has a relatively easy-to-use website to apply and file claims.

How is Nationwide Insurance Rated?
J.D. Power (out of 1,000)816
A.M. Best - Financial Strength RatingA+
BBBA+
NAIC Complaint Index0.88

Nationwide Homeowners Insurance Pros & Cons

Pros
  • Customers can file and track home insurance claims online.
  • Personalized service due to the availability of local agents.
Cons
  • Coverage in Washington, D.C., and every state except Alaska, Hawaii, Louisiana, and Massachusetts.
  • Doesn’t insure mobile or manufactured homes.

Chubb: Best Insurance Coverage for High-Value Properties

chubb-homeowners-insurance.jpg
Editors star rating review
Editor's Rating (4.5 Stars out of 5)

Chubb is great for those who own expensive homes or luxury estates.

Because of that, you can select higher liability costs than the typical homeowners insurance policy, with coverage up to a high $100 million.

Say if you don’t want to rebuild your home after a total loss, the policy will offer you a cash settlement.

The Chubb Masterpiece policy offers to rebuild your home if the damage of your home exceeds the limit in your policy.

The policy covers many things that are important to wealthy policyholders and includes atypical features. Among many, these stand out.

If you own a second home, property managers can take care of it in case of an emergency, such as wildfire or hurricanes.

Also, the policy offers extended replacement costs for dwelling and replacement value for your high-priced personal possessions.

Chubb Home Insurance Coverage That Stands Out

  • Security: if you live in a gated community, you’ll get a discount.
  • Contracts with certified wildfire firefighters to help protect homes from wildfires that are common on the West Coast.
  • If you lose your keys or they get stolen, the policy will put up new locks.

What Makes Chubb Unique?

Have a historic home worth over a million? You may be out of luck with some insurance companies.

Chubb is the only insurance company that specializes in covering homes and properties that are over a certain value.

Not only is your home very insurable with Chubb, but they are going to have the add-ons and plans that you need for your high-value possessions.

Chubb also offers arguably the best coverage for these pricey properties, particularly in high-risk areas prone to hurricanes and flooding.

While getting an insurance estimate from Chubb may be a chore considering you have to speak to an agent, it also makes it easier to customize to your exact needs.

Chubb Homeowners Insurance Pros & Cons

Pros
  • High-end policyholders can choose their contractors and landscape designers to make repairs after a claim.
  • Customized coverage for wealthy families is available (at a cost).
  • Complaint level for issues with coverage is rated “excellent.”
  • Offers free home appraisals to all customers free of charge.
  • Deductible waived if claim is over $50,000.
Cons
  • Only insures high-value properties.
  • The Chubb Masterpiece coverage comes at a high cost.
  • Since the insurance is designed for expensive homes, the policy also tends to be expensive.
  • You can’t get an instant quote online. If you want to sign up for a policy, you have to go through an agent.
  • Price competitiveness: fair.
How is Chubb Homeowners Insurance Rated?
J.D. Power (out of 1,000)809
A.M. Best - Financial Strength RatingA++
BBBD-
NAIC Complaint Index0.21

Amica: Best Homeowners Insurance For Handling Claims

amica-homeowners-insurance.jpg
Editors star rating review
Editor's Rating (4.5 Stars out of 5)

Amica offers some of the best coverage among other national companies.

Amica is known for offering coverage that's right for the policyholder, whether that's a package with just the basics, or extended coverage for those who need it most.

Amica is rated one of the best home insurance companies particularly for their customer service and has perks and programs not normally offered by insurance companies.

They also have nearly as much coverage area as the major national insurance companies. Nonetheless, Amica Mutual's homeowners insurance is only offered in the 48 contiguous states of the United States, excluding Alaska and Hawaii.

Amica Home Insurance Coverage That Stands Out

  • Home Business Coverage pays for work-related items such as computers and printers if they’re lost or stolen.
  • The policy also covers work-related injuries if you work from home.

What Makes Amica Unique?

Amica takes out the white gloves when it comes to its policyholders and customers.

Although you pay a little extra for your premiums, you are getting the service you look for when it's time to file a claim.

Filing a claim can become a headache in a potentially stressful circumstance you might find yourself in.

That's why ease of filing, plus getting the payout you need, can be worth every extra penny you pay for with Amica.

Amica also has a host of great discount opportunities and a contractor referral service for their customers.

In certain states, you can also buy into their dividend program that gives money back to you at the end of the year.

Amica Homeowners Insurance Discounts

  • Security. You'll get a discount if you install a burglar alarm, multiple locks for your doors, a fire alarm, a sprinkler system, and more.
  • Automatic Detection Devices. Homes equipped to monitor temperature, gas leaks, or water leaks, will give you a discount.
  • Home Credit. You may get a reduced rate if you buy new home equipment, such as appliances.
  • Multipolicy Discount. You'll get a discount if you bundle your home insurance with auto insurance or other policies.
  • Claim-Free Discount. You're up for a discount if you don’t make a claim in three years.
  • AutoPay. Signing up for automatic deductions to pay your bill can save you money.
  • Loyalty Discount. If you’ve been with Amica for at least two years, you can get a discount.
  • Paperless Discount. If you switch from paper bills to electronic bills and notifications, you’ll get a discount.

Amica Homeowners Insurance Pros & Cons

Pros
  • Best-in-class claims handling and customer satisfaction ratings.
  • Fewer customer complaints than the industry median relative to its size.
  • Outstanding perks, including a dividend program and network of contractors to rebuild your home.
Cons
  • Coverage endorsement offerings are limited.
  • Certain types of additional coverage offerings and perks like dividend policy payments aren’t available in some states.
  • Doesn’t cover all states.
How is Amica Homeowners Insurance Rated?
J.D. Power (out of 1,000)849
A.M. Best - Financial Strength RatingA+
BBBA+
NAIC Complaint Index0.32

State Farm: Best Homeowners Insurance for Dwelling Coverage

State Farm Homeowners Insurance
Editors star rating review
Editor's Rating (4.5 Stars out of 5)

State Farm’s home insurance policy has great coverage and great customer service.

But what State Farm stands out is for its “Increased Dwelling Limit.”

First, the increase is available at no cost to you.

As long as you’ve insured your home at least up to its estimated replacement cost, State Farm will automatically extend your replacement cost coverage up to 20%

For example, if the policy concludes that rebuilding your home will cost $200,000, that’s your dwelling coverage.

Now say if a covered disaster strikes your home and construction costs and hiring a contractor go up, by default the policy will pay you up to 20% more.

So, you’ll get $240,000 to rebuild your home.

State Farm Home Insurance Coverage That Stands Out

  • State Farm’s website and app make it user-friendly to file a claim or get a quote from the comfort of your sofa.
  • The site has a “find an agent” tool that can quickly connect you to a live customer service rep.

What Makes State Farm Unique?

Sometimes size and history matter.

State Farm seems to have proven that with its extensive network, which spans all 50 states and has been helping homeowners since 1922.

However, their agents aren't just scantily sprinkled here and there.

Their network is robust, which, in turn, gives their availability to their policyholders, especially when it comes to filing a claim.

They also make navigating homeowners insurance simple making it perfect for first-time homeowners.

Plus, the ability to up your dwelling coverage at no additional cost doesn't hurt your cause either.

Read a full State Farm homeowners insurance review.

State Farm Homeowners Insurance Pros & Cons

Pros
  • The simplicity of the website and app is great for first-time homebuyers.
  • If you have energy-efficient appliances, you can get coverage for that.
  • Utility lines and even waterbeds are qualified for coverage.
  • You get a discount if you have a damage-resistant roof.
  • Agents offer personalized service.
Cons
  • State Farm is the most affordable insurance company, but that’s only if you bundle.
  • Limited discounts.
  • Lower than average consumer satisfaction with homeowners claims.
  • Flood insurance requires a separate policy.
  • Some features are only available in a package.
How is State Farm Homeowners Insurance Rated?
J.D. Power (out of 1,000)829
A.M. Best - Financial Strength RatingA++
BBBA+
NAIC Complaint Index1.77

Farmers: Best Home Insurance for Its Extensive Agent Network

Farmers Homeowners Insurance
Editors star rating review
Editor's Rating (4 Stars out of 5)

Customer service is ranked high for Farmers because you can call a live agent to buy a policy or make a claim.

Using a website or app for homeowners insurance is certainly convenient, but customers in the older range or who are technically challenged would rather consult with an agent.

Also, policyholders value building a relationship with an agent over time so when it’s time to speak with a customer service rep, they get personalized coverage.

Farmers Home Insurance Coverage That Stands Out

  • With optional coverage, if you need to replace large-item possessions such as a TV or an appliance, your policy with cover the current prices without depreciation.
  • If you pay on time, you can get a discount.
  • You can get a discount of up to 10% if you don’t make any claims for three years or more.

What Makes Farmers Insurance Unique?

Farmers is one of the largest insurance companies in the country, available in all 50 states with 48,000 agents.

It's easily one of the most accessible insurance companies for homeowners.

They also offer tiered coverage options so it's easy for homeowners to purchase a policy that best fits their needs.

Farmers also offers more competitive premiums than most large brands.

Farmers Homeowners Insurance Pros & Cons

Pros
  • Agents offer superior customer service.
  • The policy provides identity theft protection and credit monitoring for a hard-to-beat cheap rate.
  • Claim forgiveness prevents a rate increase for longtime customers after their first claim.
  • Discounts are available for teachers, doctors, and certain other professions.
  • Deductibles decrease over time if no claims are made.
Cons
  • Using agents means service is not always available 24/7.
  • Farmers is the most expensive insurance company.
  • Policy claims you can get a quote using the app and website, but it only takes your information and passes it on to an agent in your region.
  • Some coverages are only available as part of a package.
How is Farmers Insurance Rated?
J.D. Power (out of 1,000)792
A.M. Best - Financial Strength RatingA
BBBA-
NAIC Complaint Index0.56

Erie: Best Policy That Pays the Full Cost of Your Home

Erie Homeowners Insurance
Editors star rating review
Editor's Rating (4.5 Stars out of 5)

Erie stands out for its guaranteed replacement cost coverage.

If your home is destroyed or damaged and is declared a total loss, Erie guarantees that it will pay the full cost to repair or replace your home even if the expense exceeds the face value of your policy.

However, this policy, which is standard for Erie, is only available in only 13 states. The following states are covered according to their website: Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Maryland, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Virginia, Washington D.C., West Virginia, and Wisconsin.

Erie Home Insurance Coverage That Stands Out

  • Unlike competitors, Erie covers damage caused by falling trees or branches. This is part of Erie’s standard policy.
  • Personal liability coverage follows you wherever you go in the world and is not just available when you are at home.
  • Fire insurance is included in the standard policy.

What Makes Erie Insurance Unique?

Although Erie is currently only available in 13 states, it does exceedingly well to cover those homeowners.

With Erie, you're guaranteed the replacement cost of your valuables, and the option to fully rebuild your home regardless of the cost is rarely seen included with base coverage.

Erie Homeowners Insurance Pros & Cons

Pros
  • Erie’s level of customer complaints is lower than expected given the company’s size.
  • Many perks and coverage options.
  • Unlike many of its competitors, Erie’s standard policy covers loss caused by mold or dry rot up to $10,000.
Cons
  • Buying a policy is only through licensed agents, which means you can’t buy or get an estimate online.
  • No app.
  • Since discounts vary from state to state, you don’t know your savings until you contact an agent.
How is Erie Insurance Rated?
J.D. Power (out of 1,000)835
A.M. Best - Financial Strength RatingA+
BBBA+
NAIC Complaint Index0.65 (Average)

Progressive: Best Homeowners Insurance for Tailored Plans

Editors star rating review
Editor's Rating (4 Stars out of 5)

Progressive homeowners insurance is among the most comprehensive and affordable in the industry.

The insurer wants you to save, so it offers three plan options to fit every budget.

Most insurers don’t allow you to choose; they only offer a basic policy and, to make it more comprehensive, you have to increase your coverage limits or add endorsements.

The Basic Plan

This plan is at the lower end, lower than a basic plan. It is designed for those who only need the most basic and simplest coverage.

However, you receive less medical payment coverage and higher deductibles.

Mid-Tier Plan

This is essentially the standard plan that every insurer offers.

Deluxe Plan

If you purchase this plan, you’ll have a higher premium. However, you’ll get more replacement cost coverage, more liability limits, and water backup protection is included.

With these three plans, you have the option to save because you are only buying coverage you need.

What Makes Progressive Unique?

If you have Progressive insurance on your car, RV, or other vehicle and want to have all of your insurance policies through the same company, you can bundle home and auto together and get the multi-policy discount.

Also, besides excludable natural disasters like floods and earthquakes, Progressive offers sinkhole insurance and landslide and mudslide insurance.

In addition, Progressive has coverage for water backup that can damage your home and the property within it.

Progressive Home Insurance Coverage

  • Progressive has an online HomeQuote tool, which allows you to compare quotes from multiple providers of homeowners insurance.
  • A basic policy never covers earthquakes and floods. And some insurers don’t even offer earthquake and flood insurance. Progressive allows you to buy insurance for both.
  • You can buy additional coverage for personal injury suits, which include types of cases like false arrest, wrongful eviction, and libel or slander.

Progressive Homeowners Insurance pros & Cons

Pros
  • Many discount options.
  • Automated security systems like fire alarms, burglar alarms, and sprinkles can help you save money.
  • New homeowners qualify for a price reduction even if the home itself isn't actually brand new.
  • Available nationwide.
  • Strong financial backing.
  • Online comparison shopping tool.
  • Online quote tool can calculate an accurate replacement cost for your home.
  • Website has helpful resources and an online chat tool to answer questions.
Cons
  • Operates as broker, underwritten by third-party partners.
  • Exterior home inspection is fairly standard when buying insurance.
  • To file a claim, you may have to go through a third-party underwriter rather than report it to Progressive.
  • Dogs that are statistically more likely to bite people or cause serious injuries can be more expensive to insure.
How is Progressive Homeowners Insurance Rated?
A.M. Best - Financial Strength RatingA+
NAIC Complaint Index1.66
Compare the Best Homeowners Insurance Companies
CompanyPropertyNest RatingJ.D. Power (out of 1,000)A.M Best RatingBBB Rating
Allstate5.0815A+A-
USAA5.0884A++A+
Lemonade4.5870*Not RatedB+
American Family4.5842AA
Erie Insurance4.5827A+A+
Farmers4.5839*AA-
Liberty Mutual4.5805AA+
State Farm4.5829A++A+
Chubb4.5809A++D-
Hartford4.5839A+A+
MetLife4.5904*A+D-
Nationwide4.0816A+A+
Progressive4.0819*A+Not Rated
Amica4.0849A+A+
Travelers4.0794A++A
GEICO4.0869*A++A+

Compare the Best Local Homeowners Insurance Companies

We've made our recommendations above based on insurers that are widely available throughout the country. But we found some of the best and cheapest for homeowners were locally-based insurance companies:

How We Ranked and Picked the Best Homeowners Insurance Companies

There are many homeowners insurance companies on the market, and it can be hard to differentiate which is best and which is affordable.

In making our selection, we took many factors into account, including customer reviews, policy discount offers, and customer service.

The following criteria had the biggest impact on which insurance to put on our list.

Online Research

We perused sites that reviewed homeowners insurance and kept an eye out for those that were rated highly by rating companies like AM Best and BBB.

Of the many sites we looked at, a few stand out, such as Forbes, US News & World Report, and Money.

Customer Reviews

We looked at customer reviews from many sites.

Pricing

Most people need additional coverage to protect their assets. It turns out that a standard policy is insufficient for many as the policies only cover the most basic features.

So, we considered how much it would cost to cover additional coverage.

Features

We also looked at companies that had the best features specific to their category; from the best policy that fully insures a home after a fire to the best policy that had excellent customer service.

Ultimately, we focused our list on those insurance companies that had unique features, such as a policy that covers medical bills and visits to veterinarians if your dog gets sick.

So, we also chose homeowners insurance that we felt was a fair balance between price and highly-coveted features.

How Homeowners Insurance Works?

You want a policy that fits your need. It should cover the right amount for your property and your belongings or offer add-ons that increase your coverage for expensive items like jewelry and art.

Homeowners insurance protects your home and personal possessions due to damage caused by theft, fire, or vandalism. It also covers liability and bodily damage.

It protects your most valuable assets, so you don’t have to pay out of pocket for damages, say, from your dog biting your neighbor on your property.

If you didn’t have home insurance, you would have to cover any medical bills and related expenses.

So homeowners insurance protects you from unforeseen financial setbacks. 

Angela Orbann
Angela Orbann
Vice President - Property, PI Product Management at Travelers
How should a first-time home buyer approach finding home insurance?
The first step should be to do extensive research to find a fair price and coverage that fits the home's specific needs. If the home is in a high-risk zone for earthquakes or flooding or has a pool or basement, it’s important to consider these factors when deciding to ensure that the policy is inclusive of these external factors. First-time buyers should also be aware that flooding is not covered under standard home insurance policies.

What Does Homeowners Insurance Include?

While coverage may vary from policy to policy, the standard home insurance varies little and always covers six distinct types of coverage.

DwellingCovers damage to your house and attached structures like a porch.
Covers stand-alone structures on your property, such as a fence or a shed.
CostFor damage to your house, the insurance will pay enough to rebuild your house or structure.
For damage to stand-alone structures, the insurance will typically pay you 10% of your dwelling coverage.
Personal PropertyPays to repair or replace belongings that are stolen or damaged in a covered event.
Cost: 50% to 70% of your dwelling coverage
Living ExpensesPays temporary living expenses while your home is repaired or damaged and which must be covered by your policy, such as lodging, meals, and other extra expenses, like laundry service.
Cost: 20% of dwelling coverage
LiabilityPays if you injure someone or cause property damage unintentionally or through neglect.
Liability coverage also pays for legal defense and settlements if you are sued for an injury or property damage.
Cost: $100,000 to $500,000.
MedicalPays if someone is injured on your property and needs medical treatment, regardless of who’s at fault. Also pays if you, a family member, or a pet like a dog injures someone elsewhere.
Cost: $1,000 to $5,000.

Do I Need Homeowners Insurance?

Homeowners insurance coverage is not required by law. However, if you have a mortgage, the lender will most likely require you to insure your home to protect its investment.

But even if you don’t have a mortgage, it’s best to get a policy because it gives you peace of mind.

How to Compare Homeowners Insurance

If you want the most affordable policy, you should compare quotes and look at discounts. Get price quotes from multiple companies.

Go online to a company’s website and see if you can get free quotes.

Try to find information about a company relating to how fast it can reimburse you for a claim.

Once you find a company you like, research it thoroughly to see what coverage it has and what coverage it doesn’t have.

Look at sites about home insurance that gives you rankings of the best policies and why.

Often these sites will give you companies that rate home insurance policies. You should be on the lookout for how many stars an insurance was given or the number of positive reviews.

For example, check out the Better Business Bureau (BBB) to see what grades it gave to homeowners insurance companies.

Once you are through, you’ll have a ballpark figure of not only the cost of the policy but also the amount of additional coverage you may need to cover valuable items like expensive clothing and artwork.

Remember, a standard policy will only cover a limited expense that’s not up to the full value of your most prized possessions.

This is why you should get a rider or additional coverage from a company to fully cover your expensive items like jewelry.

And also remember that the more coverage you add, the more you’ll have to pay.

Allen Anderson
Allen Anderson
Senior Vice President, Selective Insurance
What are some of the pitfalls homebuyers can look out for in a property when getting insurance for their new purchase?
The biggest mistake a person can make is focusing purely on the policy's price. In the excitement of purchasing a new home and assuming all the related costs, don't try to cut expenses by reducing your insurance coverage, and don't agree to a policy without understanding what it covers.

How Much Homeowners Insurance Do You Need?

If you can ascertain the cost to rebuild your house if it gets destroyed, this is the foundation and starting point of how much insurance you need.

The amount is called your dwelling coverage.

After adding in add-ons, umbrella insurance, and insurance riders (also an add-on to an insurance policy that amends a basic policy), you’ll be able to figure out how much extra funds you need in addition to the cost of a basic policy.

If you still don’t know how much additional coverage you need, try to price each prized belonging.

If you have receipts, that’s even better.

This is called a home inventory and is the best way to designate how much it would cost to replace your items.

Also, an inventory can come in handy when it’s time for you to make a claim.

Once you do your home inventory, only then will you be able to choose wisely in terms of coverage.

What Additional Coverage Do You Need?

Dwelling coverage should reflect the cost to rebuild or repair your home based on labor, the cost of contractors, and the materials needed.

Many policies only pay up to a limit, so you should look for replacement cost coverage.

Often this added policy will pay the full cost to rebuild or repair your home.

Expensive Possessions

You should also “schedule” high-priced belongings.

A company will only pay up to a certain amount for items like expensive jewelry.

If you need more protection coverage, you can “schedule” them for their appraised value.

“Schedule” is a supplemental policy that extends coverage.

By buying a scheduled personal property policy, owners can ensure full coverage of expensive items, such as jewelry, in the event of a claim.

Replacement Cost vs. Actual Cash Value (ACV)

Replacement cost coverage is better than ACV because it pays to replace something like an expensive laptop by giving you a brand-new comparable version.

In contrast, ACV only reimburses you for an item’s depreciated amount.

So, if your expensive laptop is five-years-old and was damaged or destroyed, expect to only be reimbursed for a five-year-old laptop.

So. it’s wise to choose replacement cost coverage to recover your items.

Additional Liability

Standard liability insurance pays for injuries and property damage. If your liability coverage is low, you may have to pay out of pocket for any amount over your policy limit.

The best way to protect yourself and others is to buy a sufficient amount of liability insurance.

Don’t know how much? The general rule is to buy enough insurance that covers your net worth or the cost you stand to lose if you are sued after injuring someone.

This is called umbrella insurance.

It’s a fairly affordable way to add more liability coverage.

Also, if there are features on your property, like a trampoline or a pool, that raises your liability risk because these items are more susceptible to injuring someone, you should get additional coverage.

Buy Additional Insurance for Natural Disasters

Floods, earthquakes, and landslides aren’t covered by home insurance.

For example, a policy might cover water damage if your roof leaks due to a hurricane, but it won’t cover flood damage from the same hurricane.

For coverage, you need special policies such as flood insurance or earthquake insurance.

Read more: Best Flood Insurance Companies

How to Get a Discount on Your Homeowners Insurance Policy

If your premium seems too high, many policies offer discounts. Below are the most commonly seen discounts with insurance companies.

However, it's important to inquire directly with your insurance company as your company may either not offer these discounts or have additional ones you might qualify for.

Common Home Insurance Discounts
BundlingDiscounts for bundling multiple properties or auto and home insurance together.
Security SystemsIf you have a home security system, deadbolt locks, burglar alarms, and more, you’ll get a lower rate.
Automatic Detection DevicesHomes equipped to monitor temperature, gas leaks, or water leaks, will give you a discount.
Home CreditIf you buy new home equipment such as appliances, you qualify for a reduced rate.
Claim-Free DiscountIf you don’t make a claim in a set time that varies from policy to policy. you’re also entitled to a discount.

How Much Does Homeowners Insurance Cost?

A typical average cost of homeowners insurance in the US is around $1,500-$2,300 a year.

But depending on your location and the extra coverage you buy will affect your total cost.

Learn more about homeowners insurance costs by state.

For a detailed look at your cost, the following is what insurers typically consider when giving you a quote:

  • The amount to rebuild your property.
  • The condition and age of your home.
  • Distance from your home to the nearest fire hydrant.
  • Your town’s fire protection rating.
  • Your claims history.
  • Your coverages, limits, and deductible.

Learn what type of homeowners insurance coverage you need to insure from fire damage.

Angel Conlin
Angel Conlin
Chief Insurance Officer at Kin Insurance
What are homeowners' most common mistakes when purchasing home insurance, and how can they avoid them?
Choosing Too High of a Deductible. You can save money on your home insurance if you choose a higher deductible. This increases your responsibility in a claim, and that ultimately saves the insurance company money. However, you want to be cautious if you go this route. Raising your deductible reduces your premium, but you also have to come up with that amount if you have a claim. Before committing to a deductible, do the math on how much savings you’re really getting. At some point, the savings may not be worth it if you don’t have an emergency fund to pay for losses. One tip people use is to take the savings from a higher deductible and put that into an emergency fund to build that nest egg. But you have to be disciplined to do this.

Which Homeowners Insurance is Right For You?

When purchasing homeowners insurance, premiums and rates should be just one of the many factors you consider.

There might be some overlap in the type of coverage, ease of claim-filing, or premiums between the top insurance companies we named but each one of them is at least a little bit better than others for different things.

For example, Amica is known for special perks and great customer service when processing insurance claims.

Chubb is best known for the coverage their policies offer for high-valued properties.

And Lemonade offers excellent premiums and functions entirely online for those who prefer to avoid phone calls.

Type of coverage and add-ons should be your primary concern, particularly when it comes to how much of your dwelling and possessions are covered, how much deductibles are, and whether the policy will cover costs to rebuild your home.

Customer service should also be paramount when considering policies because with the right company it can be a smooth experience to get your insurance claims processed but a nightmare with the wrong company.

So, it's important to do your own individual research.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Not Covered by Standard Homeowners Insurance?

Standard homeowners insurance policies typically do not cover valuable jewelry, artwork or other collectibles. These are often bought as a secondary investment and can be very expensive depending on their condition; in order to protect them you should purchase special coverage through your agent which includes protection from damage caused by an earthquake or flood.

Are Appliances Covered Under Homeowners Insurance?

Homeowners' Insurance does not cover the cost to repair or replace an appliance as a result of normal wear and tear. However, homeowners policies do provide coverage for appliances lost due specifically caused by natural disasters such as fire or lightning strike..