6 Best Homeowners Insurance Companies in Hawaii of 2023
Owning a home has been part of the American dream from the time our country was founded, and it’s part of what many Americans think of as success.
Homeowners in Hawaii must protect themselves by purchasing homeowners insurance to provide them with coverage if their home is damaged or destroyed.
Purchasing insurance is particularly important in Hawaii, where damage from earthquakes, tides, and storms is common.
Whether you live in a major city like Honolulu or a small town like Kailua or Lahaina, buying homeowners insurance will give you the peace of mind you deserve.
At PropertyNest, we want every homeowner in Hawaii to have a stress-free experience shopping for and buying homeowners insurance. We have researched for you to pick the best homeowners insurance companies in the state.
You should know that hurricane insurance is supplemental to home insurance in Hawaii, which explains why the state annual average for homeowners insurance is one of the lowest in the country at $985, well below the national average.
It’s important to note that hurricane insurance does not cover flood damage, so you may also want to purchase flood insurance.
Best Homeowners Insurance Companies in Hawaii
- Allstate: Best for Filing Claims
- State Farm: Best for Automatic Inflation Adjustments
- USAA: Best for Active Military Members and Veterans
- Island Insurance: Best for Local Service
- Chubb: Best for High-Value Homes
- RLI: Best for Hurricane Insurance
Allstate: Best for Filing Claims
- Available in 50 states & Washington, D.C.
- Quote access: Online & by phone
Allstate Insurance is a large company with a proven track record of protecting homeowners that goes back decades.
We chose Allstate for our list because their user-friendly website makes filing and tracking claims easy.
We also like that Allstate will work with FEMA to help Hawaii homeowners file and track flood claims.
Allstate’s average annual homeowners insurance premium in Hawaii is just $360, putting it below the national average; remember, this doesn’t include hurricane insurance.
Allstate Homeowners Insurance Discounts
Allstate has an impressive array of 8 discounts for homeowners insurance, several of which are accessible to most homeowners in Hawaii.
- Multi-policy: You’ll get a discount if you purchase two or more policies with Allstate.
- Early signing: Sign your new Allstate policy a week or more before your old policy expires to get this discount.
- No claims: You’ll get this discount if you have not filed a recent homeowners insurance claim.
- New roof: Get this discount if you replace your roof.
- New homeowner: Get a discount if you have just purchased a home or a newly built home.
- Responsible payer: You’ll earn this discount if you pay your monthly premium on time.
- Protective devices: Any homeowners with installed fire or theft prevention devices can get this discount.
- Welcome: Switch your insurance to Allstate to get a 10% discount.
Read a full Allstate homeowners insurance review.
Allstate Homeowners Insurance Pros & Cons
- Filing a claim with Allstate is easy thanks to their user-friendly website.
- You can use the Rate Guard option to lock in your premium.
- Allstate provides flood claim facilitation through FEMA.
- HostAdvantage coverage will protect you if you share or rent your home.
- Allstate offers an array of add-on coverages, including yard & garden repair and hurricane insurance.
- There is a digital identity tool available as an add-on.
- Replacement cost coverage does not come standard.
- Hurricane policy deductibles may be higher than standard deductibles.
|J.D. Power (out of 1,000)||815|
|A.M. Best - Financial Strength Rating||A+|
|NAIC Complaint Index||2.05|
State Farm: Best for Automatic Inflation Adjustments
- Available in 48 states & Washington, D.C.
- Quote access: Online & by phone
State Farm has been selling insurance since 1922 and is one of the most highly respected insurance companies in the United States.
We selected State Farm for this list because they offer automatic inflation adjustments, something that’s particularly important in Hawaii, where consumer prices tend to be higher than average.
We also like that the company has excellent customer service reviews and that there are flexible policy limits for homeowners with high-value properties.
The average annual homeowners insurance premium in Hawaii for State Farm is $435, below the state average, and does not include hurricane insurance.
State Farm Homeowners Insurance Discounts
State Farm provides only three discounts on homeowners insurance, including two that most Hawaii homeowners can qualify for.
- Policy bundling: According to State Farm, homeowners can save an average of $1,127 annually by bundling auto and home insurance.
- Home security: If your home has installed fire alarms, smoke detectors, burglar alarms, or a home monitoring system, you can get this discount.
- New roof: If you replace your roof with impact-resistant materials, you can save on your homeowners insurance.
Read a full State Farm homeowners insurance review.
State Farm Homeowners Insurance Pros & Cons
- State Farm offers an optional Inflation Guard rider that protects you by automatically increasing your dwelling coverage limit to adjust for inflation.
- Expanded and Premium coverage are available for high-value homes and include coverage for equipment malfunction and water backup.
- State Farm also offers an optional fungus & mold rider.
- Each homeowner who buys coverage will receive free information about emergency services as well as free catastrophe protocols.
- State Farm offers only three discounts on homeowners insurance.
- Choosing the Expanded or Premium coverage options will put your premium above the state average.
|J.D. Power (out of 1,000)||829|
|A.M. Best - Financial Strength Rating||A++|
|NAIC Complaint Index||1.77|
USAA: Best for Active Military Members and Veterans
Hawaii is home to many active-duty military members and veterans who live and serve on the island’s military bases.
We selected USAA for our list because they offer affordable coverage to current and former military members and their families, including covering the replacement cost of uniforms.
We also like that the company has top-notch customer service and is available in all 50 states plus Washington, D.C.
USAA has costs higher than average in Hawaii, coming in at $1,575, significantly higher than the state average. Still, some military members may prefer to work with a company that offers special protection for them.
USAA Homeowners Insurance Discounts
USAA offers three standard discounts for homeowners insurance.
- Policy bundling: Save on both policies if you bundle auto and homeowners insurance.
- Security system: You’ll get a discount if you have a monitored security system.
- Claims-free: You can claim this discount if you have been claims-free for five years or more.
USAA Homeowners Insurance Pros & Cons
- The company has received excellent ratings for customer service.
- There is unique coverage available for military service members.
- Replacement cost coverage is standard.
- Coverage is not available to civilians.
- Local service is limited.
|J.D. Power (out of 1,000)||882|
|A.M. Best - Financial Strength Rating||A++|
|NAIC Complaint Index||0.88|
Island Insurance: Best for Local Service
Island Insurance is based in Honolulu and is the largest Hawaii-based property and casualty insurer and one of the top 50 property and casualty companies in the US.
For more than 80 years, Island Insurance has been providing local service to Hawaii homeowners, and that’s why we chose them for our list.
We also like the company’s commitment to providing affordable insurance to underserved communities, which is embodied by their “Always Here to Help” motto.
The average cost of a policy with Island Insurance is $920 per year, slightly below Hawaii's state average.
Island Insurance Discounts
Island Insurance offers four discounts on homeowners insurance.
- Island package bundle: If you bundle homeowners and auto insurance, you can save 18% on auto insurance plus $50 off per eligible vehicle and save 10% on homeowners insurance.
- Renewal credit: Renew your policy to get a credit toward your premium.
- Alarm and protection discount: You’ll get a discount if you have approved and properly maintained installations of fire protection systems or alarms.
- Age of dwelling discount: If you own a home that’s less than 20 years old, you can get this discount.
Island Insurance Pros & Cons
- Island Insurance policies include $5,000 of Loss Assessment coverage at no cost.
- Equipment breakdown coverage is also included at no cost.
- Island Insurance provides local service, making it a good choice for Hawaii’s homeowners.
- Quotes are not available online and must be obtained through an agent.
- The company’s website could be more user-friendly.
|A.M. Best - Financial Strength Rating||A|
Chubb: Best for High-Value Homes
Chubb is the world's largest publicly traded property & casualty insurer and has a solid reputation for providing affordable insurance.
We put them on our list because they have the best coverage for high-value homes, protecting against natural disasters.
Chubb’s Masterpiece Homeowners policy protects homes worth more than a million dollars.
Chubb’s annual cost of homeowners insurance in Hawaii is in line with the overall state average, but buying a policy for a high-value home may put your costs above average.
Chubb Homeowners Insurance Discounts
Homeowners in Hawaii can save with Chubb’s six homeowners insurance discounts.
- Backup generator: You’ll get this discount if you install a permanent backup generator.
- Claims-free: You can save as much as 10% if you’ve been claims-free for three or more years.
- Fire & security: You’ll get a discount if you have installed fire alarms, sprinklers, or fire-resistant construction or if you have a security system.
- New/renovated home: You can save up to 17% if your home is newly renovated and as much as 24% if you live in a newly constructed home.
- No mortgage: You’ll get a 10% discount if you have paid off your mortgage.
- Policy bundling: Get a 10% discount if you bundle your homeowners policy with auto or life insurance.
Chubb Homeowners Insurance Pros & Cons
- Chubb has its own flood insurance, which can be added to homeowners insurance as a rider.
- There is additional coverage available for high-value homes.
- Special coverage includes ID theft protection and water backup coverage.
- Chubb will pay to rebuild your home even if the rebuilding cost is higher than your policy limit.
- They offer a cash-out option, so homeowners can take a payout instead of rebuilding.
- Chubb’s complimentary Wildfire Defense Services and Property Manager Service helps homeowners plan for hurricanes and recover from hurricane damage.
- Quotes are not available online and may only be obtained through a Chubb agent.
- Policy limits are high and not suitable for homeowners with less expensive homes.
|J.D. Power (out of 1,000)||809|
|A.M. Best - Financial Strength Rating||A++|
|NAIC Complaint Index||0.21|
RLI: Best for Hurricane Insurance
RLI is a Hawaii-based company that offers homeowners insurance only to residents of Aloha State.
We selected them for our list because they are the only company that offers hurricane coverage as a standard option.
We also like that they provide coverage for homes in the most remote areas of the state and for homes under construction.
The average cost of a basic RLI policy in Hawaii is just $410, putting it well below the state average and making it one of the most affordable options for most residents.
RLI Homeowners Insurance Pros & Cons
- RLI offers hurricane coverage as part of its standard policy.
- Coverage is available for homes in remote areas of the islands and for homes under construction.
- The company has few customer complaints and has received high ratings for service.
- There is no option to file claims online, but there are phone and email options.
- The website could provide more robust information and self-service options.
|A.M. Best - Financial Strength Rating||A+|
What Things Impact the Cost of Homeowners Insurance?
There are a number of things that may affect how much you pay for homeowners insurance coverage, and it’s difficult for us to tell you how much your coverage will cost because we don’t have the details of your home.
That said, here are some factors that will impact your cost and may help you estimate what you’ll end up paying.
The deductible you choose for your insurance policy will significantly impact your premium.
If you opt for a low deductible, you should expect to pay more than you would for a high deductible policy, so keep that in mind.
We’ll get into more detail about how to decide on a policy limit in the next section, but as a rule, you’ll need a limit high enough to cover rebuilding your home from the ground up.
If you live in a high-value home or choose to buy extra liability protection, your premium will likely be higher than the state average for Hawaii.
Endorsements and Riders
Standard homeowners insurance policies protect your home and other structures on your property and provide limited protection for your personal liability and guest medical expenses.
Should you decide to add to your coverage with riders and endorsements, each addition will add to the total cost of homeowners insurance.
The final factor that can impact homeowners insurance costs is your home's location.
Houses close to water, far from a local firehouse, or in an area where crime or vandalism is high will cost more to insure.
How Much Homeowners Insurance Do You Need?
New homeowners often ask us for advice on how much homeowners insurance coverage to buy, and that’s a good question.
The easiest way to calculate your coverage is to use the estimated cost to rebuild your home as a guide.
- Dwelling coverage should be high enough to pay for the complete rebuilding of your home from the ground up if it should be destroyed.
- Other structures coverage pays for the repair or reconstruction of any other buildings or structures on your property, including detached garages, sheds, fences, or barns, and should equal about 10% of your dwelling coverage.
- Personal property coverage reimburses you for your belongings if they are stolen or destroyed and should total between 50% and 70% of your dwelling coverage.
- Liability coverage provides personal protection if a guest on your property is injured or their belongings are destroyed, and you should have coverage between $100,000 and $500,000.
- Guest medical payments coverage will pay for a portion of medical expenses incurred by a guest who is injured on your property, and in most cases, coverage will be between $1,000 and $5,000 per guest.
- Additional living expenses coverage will pay you and your family to live in a hotel or make alternative living arrangements if your home is destroyed or damaged to the point where it becomes uninhabitable.
Adding these numbers reveals that you’ll need approximately twice the cost to rebuild your home as a total limit, not including guest medical coverage and personal liability.
These numbers do not include any additional coverage you purchase, such as scheduled high-value items, hurricane coverage, or earthquake coverage.
What Is and Isn’t Covered by Homeowners Insurance
Your homeowners insurance policy protects you against many of the risks of being a homeowner, but it doesn’t cover everything.
Here are the things covered by a standard policy.
- Your house and other structures on your property include barns, fences, sheds, and detached garages.
- Personal belongings for you and all other occupants of your home, whether or not the belongings are in your home when they are destroyed or stolen.
- Any damage caused by covered events.
- Your personal liability is related to damage to guests’ personal property or injuries.
- Guest medical expenses.
Each coverage will be paid in accordance with your policy’s limits and deductible.
Here are the things not covered by a standard homeowners insurance policy.
- Pest infestation and damage
- Flood damage
- Earthquake damage
- Hurricane wind damage
- Power failure
- Government action
- Nuclear hazards
The first five things on the above list can be remedied by purchasing an additional policy, such as buying supplemental hurricane coverage or flood insurance from the National Flood Insurance Program or by adding a rider to your policy to cover earthquake damage.
There is no way to remedy the last three items on the list because neglect is within your control, and the likelihood of government action or a nuclear hazard damaging your home is extremely small.
At PropertyNest, it’s our goal to provide every homeowner in Hawaii with the facts they need to choose the right homeowners insurance policy to protect themselves and their property.
As you search for homeowners insurance, remember the factors that can impact how much you pay, including how much it will cost to rebuild your home, the value of your belongings, and where your home is located.
We suggest obtaining at least three quotes from three carriers to compare premiums and coverage.
Make sure to ask about any available discounts and take advantage of all that apply to you to minimize the cost of homeowners insurance.
How We Selected the Best Homeowners Insurance Companies for Hawaii
Shopping for insurance has the potential to be both stressful and time-consuming because there are many options to consider, and it may not be easy to compare companies, costs, and coverage.
We used these five criteria to choose the best homeowners insurance options for Hawaii and ensure you have the information you need to find a policy that works for you.
The amount you pay for a homeowners insurance policy will be determined by the value of your home, its location, and other factors that impact the insurance company’s risk.
For our list, we focused on companies that offer value compared to the Hawaii state average and the US national average to help you minimize costs.
When you buy homeowners insurance, you need to be confident that you have enough coverage to protect yourself and your family in the event that your home or belongings are damaged or destroyed.
We prioritized insurance companies that offer a broad range of riders and customization options, as well as flexibility in policy limits, to help you get the protection you need.
While your home's size, value, and location determine the cost of homeowners insurance, you can reduce your monthly premium if you qualify for homeowners insurance discounts.
We selected companies that provide at least three discounts on homeowners insurance, with special attention to those who offer discounts that apply to most homeowners, or whose costs were low enough to justify their inclusion without discounts.
Low premiums can’t make up for a lack of customer support, particularly if you need to file a homeowners insurance claim.
To make our list, companies needed to have a history of solid customer support and good reviews and ratings, and we gave special attention to those who provide online, mobile, or around-the-clock support.
Technology can make getting homeowners insurance quotes and coverage easy, and the same is true of filing claims.
We selected companies with user-friendly websites, online support and resources for policyholders, and well-reviewed mobile apps.