7 Min to Read

6 Best Homeowners Insurance Companies in Minnesota 2022

Learn about the best homeowners insurance companies in Minnesota, with information about costs, discounts, coverages, and more.
Minnesota-USA

Minnesota is known as the Land of 10,000 Lakes, which may explain why so many people are eager to become homeowners there.

Homeowners insurance protects your home and other structures, as well as your personal property, whether you live in a big city like Minneapolis or a small town like White Bear Lake.

While there’s no Minnesota law requiring homeowners insurance, all lenders require proof of coverage before closing on a mortgage home loan; Minnesota law does make it illegal for an insurance company to knowingly insure a home for more than its replacement cost.

The average annual cost of homeowners insurance in Minnesota is $1,880, which works out to about $156 per month.

Compare the coverage and cost of the best homeowners insurance providers in Minnesota picked by PropertyNest expert editors:

Best Homeowners Insurance Companies in Minnesota

  • Allstate: Best for Facilitation of Flood Claims
  • State Farm: Best for Inflation Adjustments
  • Travelers: Best for Green Homes
  • Farmers: Best for Extended Liability Coverage
  • American Family: Best for Optional Coverage
  • North Star: Best for Affordable Coverage

Allstate: Best for Facilitation of Flood Claims

Editors star rating review
Editor's Rating (5 Stars out of 5)

Allstate Insurance has been in operation since 1931 and today is one of the biggest insurance companies in the US.

Because Minnesota is home to so many bodies of water, we selected Allstate as one of the best carriers because they are extremely helpful when it comes to facilitating FEMA flood claims.

We also like that Allstate has a user-friendly website that’s designed to simplify the process of filing and tracking claims.

Read a full Allstate homeowners insurance editor's review.

Allstate’s average monthly cost for homeowners insurance is $240, which is above the state average.

Most homeowners can save money by layering multiple discounts.

Allstate Homeowners Insurance Discounts

Allstate offers a total of eight homeowners insurance discounts to help Minnesota homeowners save money on insurance.

  • Policy bundling. You can save if you buy two or more policies with Allstate.
  • Welcome discount. Switch your insurance to Allstate to take advantage of a 10% discount.
  • Early signing. Finalize your new Allstate policy at least a week before your existing policy expires to get this discount.
  • Claims-free. Homeowners with no recent claims can get a break on their premium.
  • New homeowner. If you’re a new homebuyer or bought a newly-constructed home, you can get a discount.
  • New roof. Installing a new roof can earn you a discount.
  • Protective devices. If your home has installed theft prevention or fire protection devices, you can save on your premium.
  • Responsible payer. Pay your premiums on time to save money.

Allstate Homeowners insurance Pros & Cons

Pros
  • Allstate will facilitate your FEMA claim if you have flood insurance.
  • The Allstate website is a good resource, user-friendly, and easy to navigate.
  • You can lock in your premium with the Rate Guard option.
  • There is an optional digital identity tracking tool to purchase.
  • HostAdvantage coverage offers protection if you share or rent your home.
  • Available endorsements include recovery of stolen electronic data, and yard & garden repairs.
Cons
  • Replacement cost coverage does not come standard with the Allstate policy.
  • There is no flood insurance available; it must be purchased through FEMA.
  • Allstate’s premiums are higher than some of the other companies we’ve listed.
How is Allstate Homeowners Insurance Rated?
J.D. Power (out of 1,000)815
A.M. Best - Financial Strength RatingA+
NAIC Complaint Index2.05
BBBA-

State Farm: Best for Inflation Adjustments

Editors star rating review
Editor's Rating (4.5 Stars out of 5)

We like that State Farm offers high policy limits for homeowners with expensive properties, but we chose them for our list because they offer a unique inflation-adjustment option that can help people save money.

We also like State Farm’s “Good Neighbor” values which emphasize customer service and support.

The average annual cost for State Farm homeowners insurance in Minnesota is $2,000, putting it slightly higher than the state average.

Keep in mind that with policy bundling, you pay substantially less than the state average.

State Farm Homeowners Insurance Discounts

State Farm offers only three discounts on homeowners insurance, but they also offer the biggest savings on policy bundling.

  • Policy bundling. You can save up to $1,130 annually if you purchase home and car insurance through Allstate.
  • Roofing. Replace your current roof with impact-resistant materials to qualify for this discount.
  • Home security. You’ll get a discount if you have installed smoke, fire, or burglar alarms or have a home monitoring system.

State Farm Homeowners Insurance Pros & Cons

Pros
  • State Farm offers an Inflation Guard rider that automatically increases dwelling coverage to account for inflation.
  • The company has top financial and customer service ratings.
  • Expanded and Premium coverage are available for high-value homes and include protection for equipment malfunction, water backup, and replacement of high-value items.
  • State Farm is one of the few carriers to offer a fungus & mold rider.
  • The mobile and online services are user-friendly and well-reviewed.
  • Your homeowners policy comes with free catastrophe protocols & information about emergency services.
Cons
  • Higher coverage limits may put your annual cost above the company’s average for Minnesota.
  • There are only three discounts available for homeowners insurance.
How is State Farm Homeowners Insurance Rated?
J.D. Power (out of 1,000)829
A.M. Best - Financial Strength RatingA++
BBBA+
NAIC Complaint Index1.77

Travelers: Best for Green Homes

Editors star rating review
Editor's Rating (4 Stars out of 5)

Travelers Insurance has been protecting Americans for 165 years, having issued its first policy all the way back in 1857.

The company has a long history of paying claims and providing excellent customer service, and that’s reflected in their ratings.

We selected Travelers for our list because they are the best choice for people with green homes or who are interested in sustainable building.

The average cost of Travelers homeowners insurance in Minnesota is just $1,560 per year, which puts it significantly lower than the state average.

Travelers Homeowners Insurance Discounts

Travelers provides five discounts to help Minnesotans save on homeowners insurance.

  • Home buyer discount. If you bought a house within a year of switching to Travelers, you’ll get a discount on your premium.
  • Bundling discount. Save up to 12% if you bundle four or more policies with Travelers.
  • Green home discount. If you have built or you own a home that’s certified as green by the Leadership Energy and Environmental Design organization, you’ll get a discount.
  • Loss-free discount. If you’ve never filed a homeowners insurance claim, you’ll save money.
  • Protective devices. Save if your home has installed burglar alarms, sprinklers, smoke detectors, or smart devices.

Travelers Homeowners Insurance Pros & Cons

Pros
  • The average cost is about 15% below the Minnesota state average.
  • Travelers offers an array of add-ons to customize your coverage, including water back-up coverage and sump pump protection.
  • Green home coverage is available to minimize the cost of rebuilding your house with green materials.
  • Travelers has received consistently high ratings for customer service.
Cons
  • Travelers’ mobile app works well for Apple users but not for Android users.
  • The bundling discount requires the purchase of four policies instead of the usual two.
How is Travelers Insurance Rated?
J.D. Power (out of 1,000)794
A.M. Best - Financial Strength RatingA++
BBBA
NAIC Complaint Index3.88

Farmers: Best for Extended Liability Coverage

Editors star rating review
Editor's Rating (4.5 Stars out of 5)

Farmers Insurance opened its doors in 1928 in California and has expanded to provide homeowners insurance in 41 states.

While Farmers offers reliable coverage at prices in line with the Minnesota state average, we chose them for our list because they offer liability coverage up to $2 million, something that may appeal to some homeowners.

We also like them because they offer tiered coverage and excellent customer service.

Minnesota homeowners pay an average of $1,880 per year for homeowners insurance with Farmers, which is in line with the state average.

Farmers Homeowners Insurance Discounts

Farmers Insurance offers four discounts to help Minnesotans save money on their homeowners insurance.

  • Claims free. You can claim this discount if you have not filed a homeowners insurance claim for at least three years.
  • No smoking. Farmers Insurance offers a unique discount for non-smokers thanks to the reduced risk of fire in their homes.
  • Policy bundling. Buy two (or more) insurance policies from Farmers to claim this discount.
  • Security. Install a fire alarm or security system that communicates with local authorities to take advantage of this discount.

Farmers Homeowners Insurance Pros & Cons

Pros
  • Farmers Insurance has the lowest number of customer complaints of any company on our list.
  • Unique tiered coverage makes it easy to customize your policy.
  • There’s a declining deductible option to reduce your deductible by up to $50 per year.
  • If you go five years without filing a claim, Farmers will guarantee that your premium won’t increase the next time you have a claim.
Cons
  • Quotes are not available online and may only be obtained through a Farmers agent.
  • While the company has excellent customer support, it is not available 24/7.
How is Farmers Insurance Rated?
J.D. Power (out of 1,000)792
A.M. Best - Financial Strength RatingA
BBBA-
NAIC Complaint Index0.56

American Family: Best for Optional Coverage

Editors star rating review
Editor's Rating (4.5 Stars out of 5)

American Family Insurance is a solid company with a long history of providing affordable home insurance to consumers in 44 states, including Minnesota.

They have an easy-to-use mobile app that can be used to compare coverage and file claims, but we chose them for our list because they offer some unique optional add-ons that can help you to customize your coverage.

You should know that in order to customize your quote, you’ll need to work with a designated agent since the customization options aren’t included in online quotes.

Homeowners in Minnesota pay an average annual premium of $1,445 with American Family, which is below the state average for homeowners insurance.

American Family Homeowners Insurance

American Family offers a total of nine discounts to help Minnesotans save money on homeowners insurance.

  • Age of home. You’ll get a discount if your home is fewer than 15 years old.
  • Autopay. Sign up to make automatic monthly payments to save on your premium.
  • Policy bundling. You’ll save if you buy two or more policies.
  • Full pay. Get a discount if you pay your premium annually in advance.
  • Generational. You’ll get a discount if your parents are American Family customers.
  • Loyalty. If you keep your policy with American Family for more than two years, you’ll get this discount.
  • Paperless. If you sign up to receive your bills electronically, you can save money.
  • Renovation. Renovate your home’s HVAC, electrical, or plumbing systems to qualify for this discount.
  • Security. Install a smart home security system to save.

American Family Homeowners Insurance Pros & Cons

Pros
  • American Family offers nine discounts to help you lower the cost of homeowners insurance.
  • The company’s mobile app is popular and well-reviewed.
  • You can buy add-on coverage to pay for hidden water damage or to pay for matching siding if some siding is damaged.
  • American Family gets strong marks for customer service.
Cons
  • Customized coverage may only be purchased through agents and quotes are not available online.
  • Prices are not as low as they are for some other carriers on this list.
How is American Family Homeowners Insurance Rated?
J.D. Power (out of 1,000)842
A.M. Best - Financial Strength RatingA+
BBBA+
NAIC Complaint Index0.25

North Star: Best for Affordable Coverage

Editors star rating review
Editor's Rating (4.5 Stars out of 5)

North Star Mutual Insurance is the only company on our list that got its start in Minnesota, having opened its doors over 100 years ago.

The company has a long history of paying claims and providing excellent customer service, but we picked it for our list because it is the most affordable option for homeowners insurance in Minnesota.

We also like that the company offers a broad array of endorsements and riders to help Minnesota homeowners customize their coverage.

North Star’s average annual cost for homeowners insurance in Minnesota is just $980 per year, putting it well below the state and national averages.

North Star Homeowners Insurance Pros & Cons

North Star offers a total of six discounts to help homeowners save money on their insurance.

  • Mature homeowner. Get a break on your premium if you’re over 55 years of age.
  • New/upgraded home. You can get this discount if you live in a newly built or upgraded home.
  • Companion policy. North Star offers a combination policy that provides both auto and homeowners insurance at a discounted rate.
  • Protective devices. Reduce your premium if you have installed fire or burglar alarms.
  • Protected subdivision. You’ll get a break on your premium if you live in a gated community.
  • Valued customer. Get a discount if you keep your policy with North Star.

On their website, North Star lists a “higher deductible” discount, but all companies have lower prices for higher deductibles, so we’re not listing it as an official discount.

North Star Homeowners Insurance Pros & Cons

Pros
  • North Star has the lowest average cost of any company on our list.
  • North Star offers a wide array of add-on coverage, including protection for identity theft, replacement of refrigerated food, and watercraft liability.
  • Unlike other companies on our list, North Star is based in Minnesota.
Cons
  • There is no facilitation of flood claims through FEMA.
  • The company’s website could provide more information about the details of available coverage.
How's North Star Homeowners Insurance Rated?
A.M. Best - Financial Strength RatingA+
BBBA+

How We Selected Homeowners Insurance Companies for Minnesota

We understand that it can be stressful to research homeowners insurance and compare costs and coverage.

Using these criteria, we selected the companies for our list of the best homeowners insurance in Minnesota.

Costs

Saving money is a priority for most homeowners because they already have the monthly expense of a mortgage payment plus other expenses.

We prioritized companies whose average costs were comparable to Minnesota state and national averages for our list.

Coverage

Each house or condo is unique, and homeowners should find a carrier that can provide the coverage they need to protect their home and belongings.

We selected companies that have multiple customization options, including tiered coverage, high policy limits, and riders and endorsements.

Customer Service

Good customer service is always desirable and can make the process of buying coverage or filing a claim as easy as possible.

We selected companies with a history of good customer service, particularly those with multiple support options.

Discounts

Discounts are one of the best ways to reduce the cost of homeowners insurance and many policyholders can reduce their premiums with discounts.

We focused on companies that offer three or more homeowners insurance discounts, particularly those that provided discounts that can apply to most homeowners.

Technology

Many Minnesotans prefer to do business online or via their mobile devices, and not every company provides those options.

We made it a priority to select companies with user-friendly websites, mobile apps, and online support that’s easy to access.

What Factors Impact the Cost of Homeowners Insurance?

While we have made sure to provide average costs for each of the carriers on our list, it’s important to note that there are several factors that can impact what you pay for homeowners insurance and may put your costs above the state average.

Policy Limits

You’ll need to buy enough insurance to rebuild your home in the event that it is destroyed, but you may also want to purchase additional protection.

If you opt to increase your liability protection or have a high-value home, then your costs are likely to be higher than the averages we’ve listed here.

Deductible

Every homeowners policy has a deductible and many companies offer an array of deductible options.

You should expect to pay more for a low deductible than you would for a high deductible.

Endorsements and Riders

Standard homeowners policies protect your dwelling and provide limited protection for your personal liability.

If you choose to add endorsements to your policy, you should be aware that each endorsement comes with a price tag that will impact your total cost.

Location

Your home’s location plays a role in determining your cost; for example, homes that are close to water or far from the closest firehouse are more expensive to insure.

The same logic applies if you live in an area with a high crime rate.

How Much Homeowners Insurance Do You Need?

How much coverage do you need to protect your home and belongings?

The easiest way to calculate what you need is to use the estimated cost to rebuild your home as a jumping-off point.

  • Dwelling coverage is the bulk of your coverage and should be high enough for you to completely rebuild your home from the ground up in the event it is destroyed.
  • Other structures coverage is the coverage that pays for outbuildings and other structures on your property, including detached garages and fences, and it should total 10% of your dwelling coverage.
  • Personal property coverage is what protects your personal belongings in the event that they’re destroyed or stolen and should be between 50% and 70% of your dwelling coverage.
  • Liability coverage protects you personally if someone visiting your house is hurt or their property is damaged, and in most cases coverage should be between $100,000 and $500,000.
  • Medical payments coverage pays a portion of medical costs if a guest gets injured in your home, and is usually limited to between $1,000 and $5,000.
  • Additional living expenses coverage pays for you and your family to live elsewhere while your home is repaired or rebuilt, and should equal 20% of your dwelling coverage.

If you add up these numbers, you’ll see that you’ll need approximately twice the replacement value of your home, not including your personal liability and coverage for guest medical payments.

You should note that if you need to schedule high-value items like electronics and jewelry, your personal property coverage may be more than what we’ve indicated here.

What’s Covered by Homeowners Insurance (and What Isn’t)

Homeowners insurance protects you if your home is damaged or destroyed or if your personal belongings are damaged or stolen, but it doesn’t cover everything.

Here are the things that you can expect to be covered by a standard homeowners insurance policy.

  1. All structures on your property, including your house, fences, sheds, detached garages, barns, and any other buildings.
  2. All personal belongings for you and your family members living with you, whether the belongings are in your home or not.
  3. Damage to your property caused by covered events.
  4. Personal liability for guest injuries or damage to their property.
  5. Medical expenses sustained by guests in your home.

Each of these coverages will be paid in accordance with your policy’s deductible and coverage limits.

Here are the items that are not typically covered by homeowners insurance.

  • Flood damage
  • Earthquake damage
  • Neglect
  • Pest damage or infestation
  • Power failure
  • Government action
  • Nuclear hazard

Some of these items, including flood and earthquake damage, pest damage, and power failure, may be remedied by adding a rider to your policy or purchasing an additional policy, as would be the case with flood insurance.

The three items that may not be remedied include government action and nuclear hazards, which are unlikely to occur, and neglect, which is within your control.

Synopsis

Here at PropertyNest, we think that every Minnesota homeowner should be sure to purchase enough homeowners insurance coverage to protect them if their home should be destroyed along with their belongings.

Keep in mind the factors we have outlined here that can impact the cost of insurance, including the value of your home and belongings, the coverage you choose, and your home’s location.

We suggest obtaining homeowners insurance quotes from a minimum of three carriers to compare costs and coverage.

We also suggest asking about available discounts and taking advantage of any that apply to you to help reduce your costs.