Allstate Homeowners Insurance Review of 2023

Uncover Allstate homeowners insurance: evaluating pros, cons, customer experiences, and coverage specifics. Decide if they fit your protection needs.
Allstate Homeowners Insurance Texas
Editors star rating review
Editor's Rating (5 Stars out of 5)

Founded in 1931, Allstate has become one of the most recognized and largest insurance companies in the nation. Servicing more than 16 million households across the country, the insurer's homeowners insurance has proven to be above average compared to others in the same sector.

With exceptional customer satisfaction ratings, a plethora of useful add-ons, a wide range of discounts, and simple digital capabilities, Allstate's homeowners insurance is found to not only be the best in the market but also the go-to option for those looking for extensive coverage options and discounts.

If you're seeking a name-brand insurer that delivers insurance plans widely recognized for its reliability and affordable pricing, Allstate fits the bill.

How Much Does Allstate’s Homeowners Insurance Cost?

The average homeowners insurance in the US costs $1,390 per year for a policy with $250,000 in dwelling coverage.

Allstate costs, on average, $1,910 per year with $250,000 in dwelling coverage.

It’s more expensive than the US average.

In addition, if you compare rates with other insurers in the same league as Allstate, Allstate still comes out as having the highest premium.

Allstate Homeowners Insurance Options

Allstate offers three options for buying homeowners insurance: the basic plan, the standard option, and the enhanced package.

Together, the tiered structures can make choosing the coverage you need more personalized while keeping things simple.

It saves you from piecing together all the extra coverages you might need if you don’t have time to do it alone.

In addition, each tier helps you decide on the cost you are willing to spend on a policy.

The Basic Plan

A basic homeowners insurance property protects both your home and the property within it.

If a fire burns down your home, your basic policy will pay to repair it.

It will even pay for your belongings inside your home ifdamaged.

It also covers medical bills if a guest comes to your home and is injured, regardless of who’s at fault.

And if the guest ends up suing you, your policy will cover the lawsuit and your attorney.

The Standard Plan

Allstate’s standard plan includes everything found in a basic plan.

In addition, it also includes:

  • Increased coverage limits for personal property, other structures on your property, such as a shed or a detached garage, and a larger amount of coverage for loss of use.
  • In addition, the standard plan has a lower per-occurrence deductible and comes with $300,000 in liability coverage.

The Enhanced Package

This plan is the best overall because it includes everything in the standard plan and comes with $500,000 in liability coverage.

It provides increased coverage for structures, personal property, and loss of use and features additional benefits that can lower your premium overall.

These benefits include:

Claim RateguardThis protects your rate from going up after a claim.
Claims-FreeFor customers who have not made any recent claims and then switch to Allstate, you’ll have a lower premium.
Claims-Free BonusThis plan gives policyholders 5% back every year they renew without having a claim.
Deductible RewardsThis takes $100 off a policyholder's deductible after sign-up and another $100 each year the policyholder stays claim-free, up to a maximum of $500.

Allstate Extra Coverage & Add-Ons

These add-ons or endorsements make your basic homeowners insurance policy more comprehensive and are never included in an insurer’s basic policy.

You pay each time you add additional coverage, which will increase your policy rate.


This unique feature, rarely seen in other insurers, is for people who rent their homes temporarily through Airbnb or a similar service.

The add-on covers theft if a home-sharing guest steals or damages your property.

Earthquakes and Floods

The basic homeowners insurance policy never covers both earthquakes and floods.

For those who live near a fault line, it’s wise to get earthquake coverage as an added cost to your policy.

While hurricanes, heavy snow, and wind are covered perils, the flood damage they cause is not.

That’s because floods caused by water that originates outside your home are never covered in a basic policy.

If you live in an area susceptible to flooding, purchasing flood insurance with Allstate is best.

Allstate will help you replace your water-damaged items; without this additional insurance, you’ll end up paying out-of-pocket.

Identity Theft Restoration

Pays legal fees and other costs if your identity is stolen.

Water Backup Coverage 

Covers damage caused by a backed-up drain or broken sump pump.

Increased Coverage

You can purchase an add-on to protect valuable items like jewelry, artwork, musical instruments, etc.

Business Property Coverage

This offers higher limits for business-related items (like computers and home-office equipment) stored in your home.

Green Improvement Reimbursement

This add-on pays to replace damaged items with energy-efficient versions after a covered claim.

Yard and Garden Coverage

This policy raises your limits on items like trees, plants, and lawnmowers.

Reimbursement Replacement

For personal property stolen or destroyed in a covered claim, replacement cost coverage will pay for brand-new items at today’s prices rather than the depreciated cost, otherwise known as actual cash value (ACV).

If there’s an item you don’t want to replace, Allstate will cover its depreciated value.

Website and Mobile App

When evaluating an insurance company, it’s always good to check out its website or mobile app.

Both should be easy to use and navigate.

In addition, these technical devices should allow you to manage most or all of your insurance needs, from getting a quote to adding coverage and from filing claims to tracking them.

Allstate’s website and app are superior and allow you to do all these things and more, such as providing you with articles and videos about homeowners insurance and allowing you to view your policy discounts.

While some insurers will not allow you to get a quote online and make you contact an agent, Allstate’s online quote tool is one of the best in the business.

It allows homeowners to get a quote online in just minutes.

And if you don’t want to file a claim online, Allstate gives you several options. You can file a claim:

  • Directly through your agent 
  • By calling its claims division 
  • Through its mobile app

You can then track your claims online, over the phone, or on the mobile app.

Allstate Discounts

While Allstate’s homeowners policy is high, the company has plenty of discounts to offset it.

Here are Allstate’s most popular discounts:

Allstate Homeowners Insurance Discounts
Multi-PolicyIf you bundle both home and auto insurance, you get 25% off your premium.
Responsible payment discountIf you pay on time every month, you’ll have a good payment history that qualifies you for a discount.
Welcome discountIf you are already covered by an insurer and switch to Allstate, you’ll get 10% off.
Loyalty DiscountUp to 10% off every year you continue to renew your homeowners insurance with Allstate.
Homebuyer discountIf you buy a newly constructed home or if you are a recent homebuyer, you’ll also save.
Easy Pay PlanUp to 5% off when you set up autopay and link it to your checking account.
Protective device discountIf you install fire alarms, deadlocks, fire extinguishers, cameras, and other security measures in your home, you’ll save. Bonus points if you live in a safe neighborhood with a low crime rate and are near a fire hydrant or fire station.
Early signing discountYou can save up to 10% if you sign a new policy with Allstate at least a week before the expiration of your current policy.

Allstate Homeowners Insurance Pros & Cons

  • Three insurance plans to choose from.
  • Bundling takes the highest percentage off your premium.
  • Easy-to-use website.
  • Well-rated mobile app.
  • Many add-ons for more coverage.
  • Several discounts can drive your premium down.
  • Local agents readily available.
  • Clear claims process.
  • Optional digital identity tracking tool.
  • Different ways to customize your deductibles and coverages.
  • Ability to see if you’ve been part of any data breaches through its mobile app.
  • Higher than average premiums.
  • Personal property limit is lower than average in comparison to similar insurers.
  • Additional Living Expenses (aka Loss of Use) are capped at a set percentage of the dwelling coverage rather than covering the total loss incurred.
  • Because Allstate employs a range of people who act as agents, customer service may vary, including factors such as responsiveness. 
  • The online quoting system allows you to schedule coverage for special items such as jewelry or furs but won't allow you to see how much they are covered for if not scheduled.
  • Online quotes not always available in some zip codes.
  • Replacement cost coverage doesn’t come standard, unlike a few other insurers.
  • If you hope to bundle, Allstate’s auto insurance has below-average customer satisfaction rankings.
How is Allstate Homeowners Insurance Rated?
J.D. Power (out of 1,000)815
A.M. Best - Financial Strength RatingA+
NAIC Complaint Index2.05

Where is Allstate’s Homeowners Insurance Available?

Allstate sells homeowners insurance in all 50 states and Washington, D.C..

How Allstate Compares to Other Homeowners Insurance Providers

Allstate vs. Lemonade: Which is Better?

Lemonade is young compared to its competitors. It was founded relatively recently, in 2015. The company provides home and renters insurance, term life insurance policies, pet insurance, and auto coverage.

The drawback is that Lemonade operates in only twenty-two states, while Allstate has no exclusions.

Lemonade’s insurance is radically different in how it operates compared to Allstate.

Lemonade operates solely on technology to provide customers with all their insurance needs. This means you do business with Lemonade using the company’s well-regarded website and convenient app.

Allstate, meanwhile, also has a website and mobile app that compares well with Lemonade’s.

However, Allstate is far more convenient than Lemonade as its traditional setup has a customer service call center where you can speak to live agents.

But unlike Lemonade, which doesn’t employ live agents to keep costs down, Allstate’s digital presence isn’t meant to replace its live customer service. It is just an added benefit for its policyholders.

The Bottom Line

For those who like the convenience of doing all their insurance needs online, Lemonade is for you.

But for those who prefer to talk to live and local reps but who like the fallback option to go online when time is of the essence, Allstate is the clear winner.

Read a full Lemonade home insurance review.

Allstate vs. Liberty Mutual: Which is Better?


Liberty Mutual is the fourth largest insurer in the U.S. Founded in 1912, the company has more than 45,000 employees and writes insurance policies in 29 countries.

Liberty is also the second-most expensive home insurance provider.

Despite its higher-than-average prices, Liberty has fewer coverage options than Allstate, so customers can’t make their standard policy more comprehensive.

However, Liberty has the same discounts that Allstate offers without noticeable exclusions.

Liberty Mutual's ratings by third-party reviewers were mixed and often below average. The bright spot is that AM Best gave the company an A rating.

Allstate received an A+, a higher rating, but in general, Allstate’s reviews were more positive than Liberty’s, making it a top choice for homeowners insurance.

Now, here is where Liberty fared worse:

JD Power’s study for homeowners and renters insurance gave Liberty Mutual a “below average” rating.

Liberty also has a much higher than average NAIC complaint index. This means Liberty received more complaints compared to insurers of the same size.

In comparison, the NAIC gave Allstate a 0 score, which meant that the insurer received fewer homeowners insurance complaints than its competitors.

The Bottom Line

While each insurer comes with pros and cons, Allstate has more positive ratings for customer service and claims satisfaction than Liberty.

As both offer the same number of coverages and have the same discounts, it’s hard to tell why Liberty Mutual has a higher premium than Allstate.

So, if you are considering a company’s affordability, then Liberty Mutual is probably not right for you, and you should research and get a quote from Allstate.

Read a full Liberty Mutual home insurance review.

Allstate vs. State Farm: Which is Better?


Allstate and State Farm are direct competitors, mostly due to their size and their popularity.

The two insurers have many things in common.

In general, they offer the same features and coverages.

Both Allstate and State Farm get top ratings from AM Best, which means they both have excellent financial strength.

However, State Farm costs less than Allstate. That’s no surprise, considering that Allstate is renowned for having high premiums for homeowners insurance.

For a $250,000 dwelling, Allstate's average annual home insurance cost is $1,910 per year.

For State Farm, the rate is $1,835.

If you are searching for the most affordable home insurer, it may be wise to go with State Farm.

But if you look at the differences between companies, Allstate comes out on top for many reasons.

State Farm has only three endorsements, while Allstate has many.

The unique ones include sports equipment insurance, green improvement, yard and garden coverage, musical instrument coverage, and deductible savings bank.

Plus, Allstate has more discounts than State Farm, for example. Allstate has many discounts that focus on being claims-free. State Farm doesn’t have even one.

Read a full State Farm homeowners insurance review.

The Bottom Line

If you are considering both State Farm and Allstate, you should choose Allstate for its breadth of coverage and discounts. You may pay more, but Allstate protects your home and assets more than State Farm does.

Augustine Reyes Chan
About the author

As a real estate professional, Augustine Reyes Chan has helped many buyers and sellers through the process of homeownership. He is an expert in the field of how-to for potential buyers, qualifying for a mortgage, and all that goes into car, homeowners, and renters insurance. Augustine Reyes Chan graduated from Columbia University with a degree in Bachelor's degree in Sociology.