Tottenville Neighborhood 2023 Review: Staten Island Moving Guide

Explore Tottenville in Staten Island: from homes for sale and rent to neighborhood safety, schools, and eateries. Get insights into real estate and local culture.
Editors Rating (3 stars out of 5)
6.2 Overall
Average Rent Prices 9
Public transportation 1
Schools 6
Lifestyle 6
Crime 9

The Tottenville neighborhood, located in the southeastern part of Staten Island, is a vibrant and friendly community with a lot to offer its residents.

Residents of Tottenville enjoy the convenience of its location being close to both the Waterfront and NYC Ferries, making it an easy commute to Manhattan.

It's also home to many beautiful parks, waterfront views, shops, and restaurants.

When people think of Staten Island, they usually don't think of quaint and quiet communities.

Tottenville, however, is just that!

This Tottenville neighborhood review will look into public transportation, restaurants, average apartment rent, and home sale prices.

Located on the southwestern tip of Staten Island, this 1.7 square mile bedroom community has experienced intense growth over the past few decades.

With some of the priciest homes in this area, it is not bizarre for a single-family home to go for at least 500K.

Fun Fact: The Conference House was the site of a 1776 unsuccessful meeting with the British in hopes of putting an end to the Revolutionary War.

Tottenville is surrounded on three sides by water - Arthur Kill on the south and west and Raritan Bay on the east.

Although Hurricane Sandy flooded much of the waterfront town, the small-town quality of life has been preserved.

Population density and crime rate still rank among the lowest in New York City.

Real Estate in Tottenville

Though most of the 19th-century homes still remain standing to this day, condominiums, townhouses, and single and multi-family homes take up most of the neighborhood.

Tottenville Beach is slightly wealthier and a very peaceful place to live, resembling a suburb rather than the city.

Development for this exclusive residential area only recently began in the 1990s. Much of the neighborhood is privately-owned housing as opposed to rentals.

Average Rental Prices in Tottenville

PropertyNest Real Estate Data As of September 2023

Finding a Rental in Tottenville

For those looking to rent an apartment in Tottenville, there are plenty of options ranging from spacious one-bedroom apartments to more luxurious two- or three-bedroom units.

These apartments offer amenities like updated kitchens, newly renovated bathrooms, and plenty of storage space. Most buildings also offer access to private parking spots.

Renters can also enjoy easy access to nearby parks, shops, restaurants, and transportation links into Manhattan or Brooklyn.

If you're looking to move, here are the average rent prices for the Tottenville neighborhood:

Currently no listings
Currently no listings

Buying a Home in Tottenville

Those looking for a home purchase have as many great options in Tottenville.

Single-family homes range from small bungalows to large historic mansions situated on sizable lots with sweeping views of Staten Island’s southern coastline.

These homes have access to some of the best schools in New York City and easy access to shopping centers and other amenities.

Condominiums are also available in a wide range of sizes and prices, offering great value for buyers who want an affordable place close to all the action.

Average Sales Prices in Tottenville

4 Beds$825,000
PropertyNest Real Estate Data As of September 2023

Public Transportation

Although most Staten Island are car owners, many still commute to Manhattan via the Staten Island Railway then by taking the free NYC ferry service.

Tottenville has recently combined their two stations into one, The Arthur Kill Station, which runs along the Staten Island Railway.

These all run to the St. George Ferry Terminal.

There are no subways to Staten Island, but maybe in the next 100 years it could be a thing...

These express buses run through New Jersey and reach Manhattan in a little over an hour.

The other bus serving the neighborhood is the SIM26 which takes passengers to Midtown Manhattan.

Bus Lines in Tottenville
Local BusesS59, S78
Express BusesSIM2, SIM25, SIM26

Restaurants & Dining in Tottenville

In Tottenville, expect to enjoy the most authentic Italian food, outside of Italy.

Though you won't get the "Little Italy" feeling because of how spread out everything is, you can be sure of an amazing Italian dining experience.

Angelina's - This hidden gem of Staten Island provides a one-of-a-kind fine wining and dining experience in a tri-level mansion right along the water. Expect deliciously unique food and top-notch service!

Not feeling so fancy? Here is a more casual option:

Reggiano's Brick Oven Pizza - Enjoy a wood-fired pizzas, heroes or other Italian classics made with the freshest, high quality ingredients. Customer favorites are the Reggiano wings and Reggiano pie.

Attractions & Nightlife

Historic sites, water views, and great walking trails are among some of the area's great outdoor activities.

The South Beach Boardwalk is a huge hit for both locals and tourists. It's a two-mile stretch of fields, water fountains, and a beach. Beach festivals and concerts are also frequently happening.

If your looking for something out of the ordinary and don't mind loud music:

Cabo Bar and Restaurant- Delicious Mexican food and fun nightlife all rolled into one! Try the crowd-pleaser - The Fiesta Sampler and you won't be disappointed.

Public and Charter Schools

Tottenville falls into district #31.

The Tottenville area has well been known for its excelling school with great sports programs.

In addition to the only private school in the neighborhood (Our Lady Help of Christians School), these public schools also serve the area:

Local Schools in Tottenville
PS 1 TottenvillePublic - PK-5 - 523 studentsVery active PTA, small class size, real community school, close-knit, great resources available, nuturing environment
P.S. 6 Corporal Allan F. Kivlehan SchoolPublic - PK-5 - 631 studentsGood after school program, strong academics, various student events, involved parents
IS 34 TottenvillePublic - 6-8 - 1165 studentsHonors program available, involved teachers, staff is easily accssible, strong support system
Tottenville High SchoolPublic - 9-12 - 3995 studentsCollege ready students by graduation, philanthropic awareness, strong music prgram, extensive exracirricular programs

How Safe is the Tottenville Neighborhood?

When it comes to safety, Tottenville offers a safe haven from the hustle and bustle of New York City.

Crime has been steadily decreasing with notable drops in homicide rates.

In addition to proactive police presence in the area, there are also several local watch groups that keep an eye out for potential criminal activity.

Crime statistics

Crime rate: 1 out of 10
Approximately 5.4880 crimes (felony) per 1000 residents
Low Medium High

Overall, Tottenville is a great place to live, with plenty of impressive amenities while maintaining a safe atmosphere.

Residents value their community above all else due to its history-rich culture, tight-knit social networks, and overall sense of security.

From picturesque parks and scenic promenades along the waterfront to great schools and stores within walking distance – Tottenville is truly one of Staten Island’s hidden gems.

Search for Home Rentals in NYC

Search for your next home based on a credit
score, price, neighborhood & more.

Find Your New Home
Rachel McCray
About the author

Originally from Florida, Rachel McCray, a writer and content producer, is now based in New York. Rachel offers expertise in New York City neighborhoods relating to real estate and history. Rachel McCray graduated from Florida Atlantic University with a bachelor's degree in Communication and Media Studies.