16 Min to Read

8 Best Renters Insurance Companies in Michigan of 2022

Augustine Reyes Chan

Augustine Reyes Chan

Looking for the best renters insurance companies in Michigan? We've put together a list of the top most affordable, reliable, and trustworthy renters insurance providers.
Street in Michigan

Michigan is considered one of the most desirable states to live in.

Renters who live in Michigan—from Grosse Pointe to Detroit—know how beautiful the state is. It is home to 11,000 crystal clear inland lakes and lush pine forests.

And Michigan’s strong job market and low cost of living make its beautiful cities extremely attractive.

But renters here should not forget about taking out a renters insurance policy.

It’s not required to have and yet it’s imperative to have.

If your rental unit was burglarized and your laptop and expensive musical instruments were stolen, you’d have to pay out of pocket to replace your belongings.

That can be thousands of dollars or more.

For only around $15 a month, renters insurance will cover your personal property if there is damage due to a storm, and also protects your belongings should your home suffer a burglary or fire, for example.

To find the best renters insurance companies in Michigan, we did the work for you. Read on to find all about what renters insurance offers. We looked at many factors, including affordability, coverage options, ways to lower your premium, and how well customer service performed.

And take a look at our list of the best companies that may help you narrow down your choices.

8 Best Renters Insurance Companies in Michigan

  • Lemonade: Best for Online and Mobile App Coverage

  • Liberty Mutual: Best for Cheapest Rates

  • Allstate: Best for Multi-Policy Discount

  • State Farm: Runner Up for Cheapest Rates

  • Farmers: Best for Customer Service

  • Progressive: Best for Discounts

  • Travelers: Best for Unique Additional Coverages

  • USAA: Best for No-Cost Extra Coverages

Lemonade: Best for Online and Mobile App Coverage

Lemonade Renters Insurance Michigan

Lemonade drastically changed the home and renters insurance industry by migrating services and live customer service agents to online using AI.

It has become an insurance darling, above all to those who grew up in the Internet age, and it’s easy to see why.

Everything is done on Lemonade’s website and on its app, which saves you time as you can get instant quotes, buy coverage, and file claims, to name a few, anytime you want from the comforts of your home.

For Michigan residents, Lemonade is a top choice because its website and app are easy to use and easy to navigate and because the company can handle 30% of claims instantly.

In most situations, your claim may be paid in as little as three minutes.

How It's Rated

  • JD Power and Associates: 870/1000 (highest rating)
  • Demotech Financial Stability Rating: A

Read the full review of Lemonade home insurance.

Lemonade Renters Insurance Pros & Cons
ProsCons
CharitableNo sales agents
Also sells homeowners, condo, co-op, life, car, and pet insuranceCan’t contact a live agent
You can now receive a discount if you bundle renters and auto insuranceYour monthly premium might be higher than $5 based on where you live and the amount of coverage you need
Intuitive website and appCoverage is not nationwide
Doing all your insurance business online provides great convenience

Liberty Mutual: Best for Cheapest Rates

Liberty Mutual Renters Insurance Michigan

Renters in Michigan who want the most affordable rate for renters insurance should turn to Liberty Mutual. Besides being best overall, the online quote we received using Liberty’s website turned out to have the lowest premium we’ve seen, which was only $5 a month.

This makes Liberty the cheapest renters insurance in Michigan.

However, you will only likely pay $5 a month if you purchase a policy with very low coverage limits. That would be $5,000. Thus, to get the standard coverage limit that’s above that limit, you’ll more likely pay around $12 a month, which is still lower than State Farm.

But there’s more to like. The insurer offers a plethora of discounts, very much more than its competitor, State Farm.

For example, the discounts offered that can bring your rate down include being claims-free, having home security, and paying your annual premium in full.

How It's Rated

  • BBB; A
  • A.M. Best: A
  • J.D. Power Overall Satisfaction Rating: 825/1,000
  • NAIC complaint index: 0.70
Liberty Mutual Renters Insurance Pros & Cons
ProsCons
Many ways to lower premiumsMediocre customer service
Good for students and young renters due to low coverage limitsThe NAIC complaint index means that Liberty received 70% as many complaints as a typical insurer
A lower limit means a lower premiumRequires a minimum of $5,000 of property
Easy online claims filingDiscount availability varies from state to state
Customer service is available on the weekends
Offers replacement cost coverage

Allstate: Best for Multi-Policy Discount

Allstate Renters Insurance Michigan

Allstate’s renters insurance has a higher premium than its competitors, namely Liberty Mutual and State Farm.

But with its multi-policy discount, that high rate will drop.

Also called bundling, when you carry both renters insurance and auto insurance from Allstate, you’ll get 10% off your auto policy and 25% off your renters policy.

That’s why Allstate’s site can boast a very low premium monthly rate that starts at just $4.

Of course, Allstate’s low rate—the lowest rate in the industry--will go up because its renters insurance is bare-bones basic and you’ll need to spend more on add-ons to get more comprehensive coverage.

But Allstate offers some very good discounts that will ultimately drive your rate down. For example, if you live in a safe neighborhood, have never made a claim for a set time, or if you are retired or older than 55, to name just a few, each of these will get you a discount.

How It's Rated

  • A.M. Best Rating: A+
  • J.D. Power Ranking: 841/1000
  • BBB: A
Allstate Renters Insurance Pros & Cons
ProsCons
Offers the best bundling discount in the industryDiscounts and policies may not be eligible for certain states
The online site is helpful and full of resourcesHigher premium for replacement cost coverage
Ability to talk to live agent despite heavy online and app presenceAverage claims process satisfaction
Different ways to customize your deductibles and coverages

State Farm: Runner Up for Cheapest Rates

State Farm Renters Insurance Michigan

State Farm renters insurance in Michigan is known for many good things.

This includes unbeatable customer service—the insurer has many agents in every state—and the company’s online presence that helps to file a claim easier and faster.

They also have a great identity restoration plan that you can get as an endorsement if your personal information is stolen. For example, if thieves hijack your identity and use it to commit theft or fraud, State Farm will reimburse you for damages.

But what makes State Farm stand out is its substantially lower rates than the competition.

The average monthly premium is only $13.

This is lower than the average cost of renters insurance in Michigan, which is around $15 per month according to the Insurance Information Institute.

How It's Rated

  • JD Power: 850 out of 1,000
  • A.M. Best: A++
  • NAIC (The National Association of Insurance Commissioners): 0.38
State Farm Renters Insurance Pros & Cons
ProsCons
The complaint index from NAIC means State Farm received only 38% as many complaints as a typical insurer of its sizeCoverage options are lacking
The JD Power renters insurance survey rating was one of the best of any renters insurance company in MichiganDoesn’t offer replacement cost coverage
Easy to contact an agentAdd-ons can be costly
Easy to use intuitive website and appOffers little discounts or any unique endorsements
No limit on personal property coverage

Farmers: Best for Customer Service

These days, most people—especially those who are young—like to maintain their renters insurance using a company’s website or app.

It’s more convenient and saves time.

But there are still a ton of renters who want to reach out and speak to a customer rep agent when they are having issues with their policy or when they want to file a claim.

Farmers is best for customer service because it places a high value on the relationship between a policyholder and a live agent.

It has an NAIC complaint index of just 0.37, which means it received about 37% as many complaints as you'd expect given its size.

This suggests that policyholders are likely to be contented with the service they receive.

And not only that, the NAIC index for Farmers is the best score overall among Michigan renters insurance companies and even beat State Farm, which received a 0.38 complaint index.

How It's Rated

  • AM Best: A
  • JD Power: 808/1,000
  • BBB: A+
Farmers Renters Insurance Pros & Cons
ProsCons
Widely availableHigher than average premiums
Easy to contactLimited and fewer discounts available than many of its competitors
Easy to file a claim with many options: website, app, call center, and text messageAverage coverage options
Low JD Power score

Progressive: Best for Discounts

Progressive teams up with third-party insurers to provide renters insurance.

Progressive is known for offering extensive named peril coverages.

But for customers, Progressive is the best in its class because of the many discounts it offers policyholders that will drive down your premium.

That’s good, as Progressive’s basic renters insurance policy in Michigan is a high $23 a month, higher than any insurer on our list.

Without the discounts, we would’ve not recommended the company.

In any event, since there are many discounts to choose from, we’ve highlighted a few.

These are the ones that policyholders can easily qualify for, not the kind like, if you never make a claim in five years with your policy, you’ll get a discount. Realistically, that’s hard to achieve.

But note first that discounts vary depending on the area you live in and which company you’re insured with as Progressive doesn’t act alone.

Discount for getting a quote at least three days before your policy takes effect.

Pay-in-full discount.

Paperless discount for communication.

If you have alarms, security features like remote cameras, or if you live in a gated community or your rental complex has a doorman or security guard, you’ll get a discount.

Discount when you bundle with another Progressive insurance, such as auto.

How It's Rated

  • AM Best: A+
  • JD Power Score: 835/1,000
Progressive Renters Insurance Pros & Cons
ProsCons
24/7 customer service. Customers can contact via phone, web, app, or online chatSells renters insurance through a subsidiary or third party, which confuses policyholders over who’s servicing the policy
HomeShield offers increased coverage for collections, watercraft, theft of firearms, and business propertyWithout discounts, policy coverage can be expensive
Additional coverage for computer and equipment, as well as business use of your personal computerRequires your social security number for you to get a quot
The app has lots of features, making it easy to file a claim or pay your bill, for exampleCoverage begins with an added fee, which makes the first month of coverage expensive
Paperless discount is only available if you do it while applying for a quote

Travelers: Best for Unique Additional Coverages

Travelers is one of the best insurers around for Michigan residents because it offers a wide range of coverage options that other companies don’t have.

It even offers coverages that are usually not available at other insurers.

Valuable Items Coverage

Valuable items provide broader coverage for expensive or special property such as jewelry, fine art, musical instruments, and computers. It allows you to add higher limits of coverage to your renters policy to cover your special items.

Usually, with other insurers, you need to get your items appraised and do a home inventory or a listing of items that you need additional coverage for. Travelers require none of these.

Contents Replacement Cost

This means your personal property in your rental can be repaired or replaced with no deduction for depreciation. This is also called replacement cost coverage.

Housing Improvements Coverage

If your landlord allows you to make alterations or upgrades to your rental, such as building a built-in bookcase, Travelers will pay if the bookshelves get damaged due to a covered peril such as fire or wind damage.

Equipment Breakdown

If your dishwasher or washing machine breaks down, Travelers will pay for repairs.

Water Backup

Water backup damage is when a drain or sewer backs up, or a sump pump fails and water comes into your rental due to heavy rain, among others. The water backup add-on covers damage to your property.

Additional Coverage Endorsement (ACE)

This protects you against libel, slander, defamation, and similar offenses. You can also purchase identity fraud protection at a cost.

How It's Rated

  • NAIC: 0.50 complaint ratio
  • JD Power Score: 807/1,000
  • AM Best: A++ (superior).
  • BBB Rating: A+
Travelers Renters Insurance Pros & Cons
ProsCons
Great coverage optionsYou can only buy policy annually rather than every month; this may be hard for people to come up with cash all at once
24/7 for claims and customer service; limited for quotesFewer add-ons than you may expect
Useful features on website and appCan’t go below $30,000 of personal property
Numerous available discountsNeed to call to get quotes in some states

USAA: Best for No-Cost Extra Coverages

USAA is dedicated to serving or retired military staff and their families.

It’s such a great insurer and offers so much that we wish USAA was for everyone.

But at least the military gets some big advantages when it comes to renters insurance.

For Michigan residents as well as for other states, USAA offers in their standard policy and to no cost to you flood, storms, and earthquake coverage.

Other insurers offer this as an add-on that you pay extra for, and which drives up your premium.

USAA also offers replacement cost coverage so you get reimbursed for your items in full at today’s price if they were damaged or destroyed due to a covered peril.

Also, the insurer offers up to $750,000 worth of personal property coverage.

How It's Rated

  • AM Best: A++
  • USAA is not BBB accredited
USAA Renters Insurance Pros & Cons
ProsCons
No monthly maintenance fee, which makes USAA very affordableOnly available for past or present military members and their families
Policies start at $10 per monthDoesn’t offer loss of use coverage; nearly every insurer offers this as part of its basic policy
Provides up to $1 million worth of liability protection
To cancel the policy, you can easily do it through the app
No ACV means no depreciated cost

How We Decided

To determine the best renters insurance company, we looked at several factors.

Discounts

Many people shopping for renters insurance avoid insurers with high monthly premiums. That’s just human nature.

But in most cases, an insurer with a high rate can still be a contender if you look at how many discounts it has, such as bundling, being clams free, and going paperless.

So, we took into consideration not only companies with a lot of discounts but also companies that look to be out of reach until you discover how many discounts they have.

Coverage

Every renter has different insurance coverage needs. So, when we evaluated insurers, we looked for companies that had a wide range of useful coverage options.

If not. we looked at endorsements and riders that extended your coverage so that you could be paid in full for your property.

Technology

We also considered if a renters insurance company had a website and a mobile app. If it did, and if both were intuitive and easy to use even for the novice, we put that company on our list.

Price

Renters insurance is supposed to give you peace of mind, so if the cost of it is higher than you would like to pay for, we took that company off our list.

Insurance providers who had low premiums or who had plenty of options to lower your premium (such as discounts), ranked higher on our list than others.

Location

We didn’t just research renters insurance quotes in the Great Lake State.

Since we needed to compare quotes to find the best policy, we looked at the most popular cities or suburbs in Michigan.

These include Detroit, Ann Arbor, Troy, Novi, Livonia, Lansing, and Frankenmuth, Michigan’s biggest tourist attraction city.

That gave us a better picture of how insurance rates vary per town.

Customer Reviews

We scoured customer reviews from many trusted sites to see how well a renters insurance company performed.

We also took into consideration rating companies such as AM Best and JD Powers to see if a particular renters insurance company, based on customer service performance, had a high score.

What Does Renters Insurance Cover?

In Michigan, the standard renters insurance policy covers liability, theft, medical treatment, and loss of use. It is the same standard policy that is offered by other insurers in the state.

Here’s the standard coverage:

Liability Coverage

Liability protects you against lawsuits from someone who has bodily injuries or property damages that you or your family caused to them.

Liability also covers your legal defense.

Personal Property Coverage

Personal property coverage pays to replace the property that’s stolen or damaged due to a covered peril.

A covered peril in a standard policy is theft, burglary, and vandalism, as well as climate changes like lightning, windstorms, hurricanes, explosions, water damage, and other events listed in your policy.

Loss of Use

This policy covers basic living expenses and temporary housing costs if your unit becomes uninhabitable due to a covered peril like a fire.

Medical Payments

This policy pays for medical care if there is bodily injury to a person that occurs in your rental unit, regardless of fault.

Is Renters Insurance Required in Michigan?

Renters insurance is not required by law in Michigan.

However, some landlords may require it for you to live in their building. They will ask for proof when you sign a lease.

Your landlord will have insurance for the apartment building or property, but that is reserved to protect or repair the exterior due to damages such as fire or hurricanes, as well as maintaining common areas such as elevators, hallways, and reception areas.

Your landlord’s insurance does not cover your personal belongings.

It’s wise to know if you plan on ditching renters insurance, the landlord’s insurance will never cover you in any form and no matter what city or state you live in.

So, it’s always a good idea to purchase renters insurance.

If you don’t have renters insurance and a fire, a burglary, or other unexpected events happen, you will be responsible for replacing your belongings, which can cost a lot of money.

If you have valuable assets such as artwork and jewelry, will you be able to afford to replace them?

Only renters insurance will make it easy for you to make replacements.

How Much is Renters Insurance in Michigan?

The premium rate for renters insurance changes for every renter.

That’s because the amount you pay depends on several factors, including, but not limited to:

Where you live (i.e. how safe your neighborhood is).

The cost of any high-value personal belongings that you plan on insuring.

How much coverage you need that goes beyond the standard policy.

When you get a renters quote from an insurer, always make sure you understand the coverage that’s right for you, so you only pay what you need.

That said, according to the Insurance Information Institute, the average cost of renters insurance in Michigan is $182 a year, or slightly above $15 a month.

This puts the state average above the national average of $180 per year.

However, if you shop around, as you should, you can find a rate lower than the state average and lower than the national average of $15 a month.

Are There Other Factors That Determine Your Michigan Renters Insurance Rate?

No Flood Area

If you live in a neighborhood that is not prone to flooding, your rate will be low. Since floods and flood damage are rare in Michigan, these things will not affect your rate.

Crime Rate

If your city or suburb has a high crime rate, you’ll also pay more. Michigan has a high crime rate, which we’ll discuss below.

Safe Neighborhood

If you live in a safe neighborhood that’s near a fire hydrant, you’ll pay less.

If your rental is in a gated community or is fortified by guards, or if you have a doorman or live on a high floor, you’ll also pay less.

Credit Score

If you have a high credit score, you’ll also get a cheaper rate.

If your score is low, you can expect a higher premium.

Claims History

If you have never made a claim for a period that is decided by your insurer, you’ll pay less.

Coverage Limits

If you have a lot of valuable belongings, your standard policy will not cover the full amount if they get stolen or damaged. As such, you need a rider to get full coverage, which means you’ll pay a higher rate.

Deductible

If you raise your deductible, your rate will be lowered.

Pets

Dog bites are common. Injuries caused by your dog are covered by your liability insurance, but you will pay a higher premium if you have a breed that is considered high risk, such as a pit bull or a Doberman pinscher.

Some insurers will flat out not cover these types of dogs.

Why is the Cost of Michigan Renters Insurance High?

The cost of Michigan renters insurance is higher than the national average of $15 a month.

That’s due to Michigan being a state that has high crime rates.

In general, renters insurance companies prefer insuring a renter who lives in a safe neighborhood that is close to a fire hydrant in case your building or rental house catches fire.

These companies want you to live on high floors in comparison to lower levels or the first level or the basement because property crimes or burglaries are more likely to occur.

Insurers also prefer that you live in a building that has security cameras and monitors as well as if you live in a doorman building, preferably if the doormen protect the lobby 24/7.

And if you have theft-protection devices like a smart camera, a deadbolt, smoke alarms, and other anti-theft devices, it makes it less likely that you’ll be a victim of crime.

Do You Need Hurricane, Earthquake, or Flood Coverage If I Live in Michigan?

Renters insurance covers wind damage, water damage, and hail.

But no matter what renters insurance company you pick, a renters insurance policy never covers flooding.

If your city or suburb is prone to hurricanes, earthquakes, and floods, it’s usually recommended that you purchase separate endorsements for these disasters so your belongings are fully covered.

In Michigan, the most severe weather is snowfall, which can be more than 16 feet.

The heavy weight of the snow and the cold temperatures can cause freezing precipitation that could result in water damage to your pipes and more.

You need to be vigilant in cleaning up snow and frozen exterior parts of your home. If you are, you should be good to go.

But other than that, Michigan is generally safe from natural disasters like hurricanes, tornadoes, and earthquakes.

These events may occur, but with less severity than in other parts of the country.

In fact, according to NOAA (National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration), Michigan has a low probability of hurricanes or tropical storms, and earthquakes are rare.

Thus, the Great Lakes region is one of the safest states in terms of natural disasters.

Damage from a hurricane is typically caused by winds and flooding.

Damage to your belongings from winds is usually covered under your renters insurance as a covered peril.

But water damage due to flooding is not covered under renters insurance.

It requires a separate renters flood insurance rider.

But you don’t need that in Michigan, which means your premium won’t rise if you had to purchase, say, flood insurance.

This also means you don’t need to purchase extra coverage for hurricanes or tornados.

How to Get Affordable Renters Insurance in Michigan

The easiest way to get affordable renters insurance in Michigan is to do your research.

This means getting quotes from as many insurers as possible. Then compare and contrast them. Which policy is the most affordable?

You can get a quote online by giving an insurer your personal information and whatever the insurer requires of you, such as if you ever made a claim with a past renters insurance company.

Usually, you can get the online quote and then buy the policy online.

In most cases, though, as soon as you submit your application, a customer representative will call you at the number you added to your application to complete your quote and for you to make a decision.

This is the best way since the insurers will be able to personalize your quote and possibly give you the lowest possible premium by applying as many discounts they offer that you may qualify for.

For example, if you opt for paperless billing and automatic payment, both will result in a discount.

But keep in mind that the most affordable insurer might not be the best.

Thus, you should take into consideration if an insurer has good customer service, such as how responsive and courteous a customer service rep is.

You can get a feel for the company when the company returns your call after getting an online quote.

Good service makes the process of buying coverage straightforward and quick. It also eases the stress of having to make a renters insurance claim.

Also, say you want to take out additional coverage so your belongings are fully covered. If the insurer puts a cap on how much coverage you can contribute, then that’s not a company you want to work with.

And before you sign with an insurer, make sure you know as much as you can about the company.

One way to do this is to talk to an insurer’s agent or customer service rep.

It is important to know all that you can about a company before taking out a renters insurance policy.

Learn about the insurance company and the protection that its policies offer before making a final decision.

Know and understand your policy limits and ask about what additional coverages you can add for your protection.

Nearly all insurers have four types of coverage that come standard in a basic policy.

As discussed, these include personal property coverage, loss of use, liability coverage, and medical payments coverage.

If you're considering an insurer that doesn't offer all of these, you should treat that as a red flag and a sign to look for another company.

Reps can also answer any questions you may have, especially about confusing things.

For example, if you go with Progressive, and you’re confused about why the company sells renters insurance through a subsidiary or third party, that’s a good question to ask.

What are the Other Ways You Can Lower Your Premium?

Many insurers offer discounts to policyholders that can ultimately lower the cost of your premium.

The most notable discounts for Michigan residents include:

Multi-Policy Discount

Discount if you bundle renters and auto insurance.

Being Claims-Free

If you don’t make a claim in a set period of time, you’ll receive a discount.

Home Security

If you install a security system, a smoke detector, or an alarm, you’ll get a discount.

Home Credit

If you purchase new and costly home equipment such as a stove or a refrigerator, you’ll get a discount.

Paperless

If you go paper-free, you’ll also get a discount.

Payment

If you sign up for autopay, you’ll get a discount.

When You Need to Purchase Additional Insurance

A basic renters insurance pays for personal belongings, but if these are high in value, they may be subject to a low limit of liability, causing your insurer to only pay up to a certain amount.

The typical standard renters insurance value cap for high-priced items like jewelry is around $10,000.

So if your jewelry is appraised at $15,000, you have to suck it up and pay the extra $5,000 if the jewelry is stolen or damaged.

To make sure that your jewelry is insured to its full value, you need to add a rider to your policy.

A rider or endorsement adds more benefits to your basic renters insurance policy.

But a rider comes with an additional cost and your premium will go up.

The good thing is that your premium won’t become terribly unaffordable. That’s because riders have low costs since they don’t involve too much underwriting.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is renters insurance mandatory in Michigan?

Renters insurance is not required by law in Michigan. However, some landlords may require it for you to live in their building.

Why is the Cost of Michigan Renters Insurance High?

Michigan renters insurance is higher than the national average due to Michigan being a state that has high crime rates.

When do you need to purchase additional insurance?

If you own multiple high-value items it might be worth investing in additional insurance. The typical standard renters insurance value cap for high-priced items like jewelry is around $10,000.