6 Min to Read

7 Best Renters Insurance Companies in Pennsylvania of 2021

Jackie Maroney

Jackie Maroney

Looking for the best insurance company to cover your home? Find out which are rated as the top renters insurance companies in Pennsylvania.

Renters insurance is a type of policy that the tenant can purchase to cover theft and damages to their personal property. The property’s insurance only handles damage and loss done to the building. Your landlord may require you to purchase renters insurance before moving in, so read the lease carefully.

Pennsylvania experiences the elements of all four seasons, so it is important to make sure your home is protected at all times. Renters insurance will cover your property if there is damage due to a storm, but also protects your personal belongings should your home suffer a burglary, fire, etc.

We did the work for you, including both smaller and larger rental insurance companies. Focusing on cost, coverage, and customer service, we were able to narrow the list down to the 8 best renters insurance providers.

Best Renters Insurance Companies in Pennsylvania

  • Lemonade: Best Overall Renters Insurance in PA

  • Liberty Mutual: Best for Customization

  • Allstate: Best Coverage

  • State Farm: Best for Comprehensive Coverage

  • USAA: Best Renters Insurance in PA for the Military

  • Progressive: Best for Discounts

  • Farmers Renters Insurance: Best Experience

Lemonade: Best Overall Renters Insurance in PA


Founded in 2015, Lemonade is one of the newer insurance providers out there. Even being relatively new, this technologically forward company has already proven itself and is quickly gaining popularity.

Lemonade makes things convenient and user-friendly for both the younger and older generations. Customers can easily file a claim, receive customer support, purchase a policy, view your policies, and more through their app and website.

There are basic policies that Lemonade provides for only $5 a month, but you can also purchase more extensive options as well.

One of the best perks about Lemonade is their philanthropic side, aka the Lemonade Giveback. Lemonade takes a flat fee for themselves and lets you choose which charity they should donate the remainder to.

What are the Discounts for Renters Insurance?

The only discount that Lemonade provides is a bundling discount (this goes for all of Lemonade’s policies, not just renters). You can shave off about 10% from your monthly premium just by purchasing multiple policies.

Bundling DiscountPurchase multiple policies to save up to 10%

Lemonade Renters Insurance Pros and Cons

Lemonade provides many pros such as being convenient, technologically advanced, affordable, and more. It is also an added benefit that they donate a certain amount to charity as well.

Cons of Lemonade include not being able to contact a live person, not being able to bundle with auto insurance, and not being available nationwide.

Any remaining money leftover from claims gets donated to a charity of your choiceCustomer support is digital; no live agents available
User friendlyOnly offers one type of discount
Affordable basic plansAvailable in limited locations

Liberty Mutual: Best for Customization


Liberty Mutual is one of the more well-known companies on this list. They allow you to keep what you want, and remove the unnecessary. Some standard coverage options include medical expenses extra living expenses, and personal property liability coverage.

Additional extras include coverage for: replacement cost, identify fraud, water & earthquake damage, and more. The fun part is creating the perfect policies for you.

What are the Discounts for Renters Insurance?

There are a few different Liberty Mutual discounts that you may be eligible for. These include online purchase discounts, multi-policy discounts, and preferred payment discounts.

Online Purchase DiscountEarn a discount by purchasing your policy online. You will receive the discount once you complete your purchase
Multi-Policy DiscountOne of their most popular discounts is their multi-policy discount. Simply purchase more than one policy to receive a discount
Preferred Payment DiscountSave time and money by registering for automatic payment and linking it to your bank account

Liberty Mutual Insurance Pros and Cons

Liberty Mutual provides several discounts and allows you to bundle your policies for even more savings. Liberty Mutual also provides a multitude of tools (such as an in-depth coverage calculator) to help you save with their high-rated app.

Their traditional policy does not include coverage for natural disasters, so these policies must be bought separately.

Has a high-rated app full of tools to help you save moreTheir traditional policy does not cover natural disasters such as floods and earthquakes - these must be purchased additionally
Provides customers the convenience of managing and tracking their claims via computer or mobile appAccording to NAIC, there is an increase in the rate of customer service complaints
Offers several discounts to help you save even moreCustomer service is not local; all representatives are in call centers nationwide

Allstate: Best Coverage


Allstate’s renters insurance policy has the basic coverage that most companies provide such as coverage for your belongings, liability, and medical coverage if someone gets hurt on your property.

If you need to move out of your home due to a natural disaster, Allstate will go one step further and will cover hotel and restaurant fees. The best part is that there is no maximum on the dollar amount that can be spent, however, there may be a 12-month max.

What are the Discounts for Renters Insurance?

Discounts are important, and Allstate luckily offers plenty. Depending on your location, you may qualify for several discounts including multi-policy and claim-free discounts. Make sure to research your policy(ies) thoroughly so you don’t miss out on lowering your renters insurance premium.

Multi-policySave money each time you purchase an additional policy
Claim-free discountYou may be eligible for a discount if you don’t have a history for filing claims
Discount for safety devices/servicesThis includes fire alarm systems, security systems, etc.

Allstate Renters Insurance Pros and Cons

Allstate’s standard policy includes coverage for additional living expenses in case you need to leave your home due to a natural disaster.

Allstate’s website is helpful and resourcefulRequires a higher premium for replacement cost coverage
You will have coverage for additional living expenses since your standard policy includes itTheir basic policies do not include coverage for earthquakes or floods

State Farm: Best for Comprehensive Coverage


State Farm provides complete coverage when it comes to both your personal and business lives. State Farm makes things even more convenient by providing banking and investment services.

What are the Discounts for Renters Insurance?

State Farm provides two discounts for renters insurance. The discounts they offer are multiple policy discount and home protection device discounts.

Multiple policy discountBundle with renters insurance and a State Farm auto insurance policy
Home protection device discountYou receive a discount if your rental has safe features such as deadbolt locks, alarm systems, fire safety equipment, and more

State Farm Insurance Pros and Cons

State Farm stays up to date with their high rated mobile app. You can get in touch with your agent as well as file/track claims digitally.

High rated mobile app for optimal customer serviceOnly provides two discounts to customers
Wide selection of discountsAverage customer satisfaction

USAA: Best Renters Insurance in PA for the Military

Families of the military should look into USAA, especially when it comes to renters insurance. These policies come at an affordable rate and provide extra coverage specific to military members.

Their standard policy includes flood and earthquake coverages. They also boast about themselves when it comes to their replacement cost coverage policy. This policy will pay you enough money to replace the stolen item.

The idea of USAA was originally born to serve members and their families of the armed services. USAA is selective with their customers because their aim to provide the best customer service available.

USAA Insurance Pros and Cons

USAA strives to make their services as accessible and affordable as possible. However, they are specific on who they allow as a member.

There are no monthly maintenance fees, which helps keep things affordable.

Zero monthly maintenance feesRequires affiliation in the military
Free ATMs nationwide and provides refunds on ATM feesExtremely limited access to live branches

Progressive: Best for Discounts

Progressive is one of the most well known and largest insurance companies in the industry. They offer deep discount offerings in a multitude of ways. Definitely research your progressive discounts as some of the policies can be expensive on their own.

What are the Discounts for Progressive Insurance?

Progressive teams up with third-party insurers to provide renters insurance.

Progressive offers several different ways to save, with discounts for pretty much anyone. You can also check to see if a competitor offers the same coverage at a lower price. Also, don’t forget the infamous “Name Your Price” tool!

Since there are so many discounts, make sure to read the fine print. If you don’t read up on all of the discounts first, then you may miss out on a deal. For example, you can receive a discount by going paperless with communication, but you can only do it while applying for a quote.

PaperlessSave money just by switching from paper to digital communication
Living in a secured or gated communityBy living in a secure property, you are showing Progressive that you keep your property safe
Paid in fullSave even more money when you front the cash for the annual policy

Progressive Renters Insurance Pros and Cons

Pros include a large library of discounts, while the major con is that some of Progressive’s policies can be expensive without a discount.

Plenty of discount optionsRequires your SSN for you to get a quote
24/7 customer service. Customers can contact via phone, web portal, app, or online chatExtra fees to start coverage are included in the down payment. Because of the additional fees, the first month of coverage is expensive.

Farmers Renters Insurance: Best Experience

Farmers renters insurance is available in 39 other states besides Pennsylvania, and is a well-known and trusted company. With over 90 years of experience, Farmers is known for their low deductibles and original discounts.

The basic insurance policy includes the main four basic types of coverage: cover for the cost of living somewhere else while your home is undergoing construction following a covered claim.

What are the Discounts for Renters Insurance?

Depending on your location, you may or may not qualify for certain Farmers renters insurance discounts.

Non-smoking policy discountReceive a discount for not having anyone smoke on your property for at least two years
Multi-policy discountPurchase an additional policy to your renters insurance, and you can qualify for a discount
Discounts for emergency personnelIf you are a police, firefighter, doctor, etc. then you can receive a special discount

Farmers Renters Insurance Pros and Cons

With over 90 years in the industry, Farmers brings plenty of knowledge and experience to its customers. The cons lie in the coverage options, where you can only add one additional option.

Over 90 years of experienceOnly one add-on coverage option available
Provides deductibles as low as $100The online quote tool doesn’t explain the coverage option or limits very well when filing a claim

How We Picked the Best Renters Insurance in PA

Finding the right renters insurance company for you depends on your personal interests and needs. Some customers may be searching for a basic cut and dry policy, where others may require a most customizable approach.

The three important factors we were looking for were on cost, policy coverage, and customer service.

Policy Cost

Renters insurance is supposed to give you security, not weigh you down with fear of your next bill. Insurance providers who had low premiums or who had plenty of options to lower your premium, ranked higher on the list than others.

If the cost of insurance is too hard for you to keep up with, then you may want to invest in a safe or safety deposit box until you can afford to keep your belongings safe.

Policy coverage

It was important that the company has a wide range of policy coverages to help accommodate your needs. Everyone is different in Pennsylvania, and that includes insurance companies.

We looked at standard coverage options as well as add-ons to make sure that you can feel your safest no matter your preference.

Customer service

You can have a great insurance company, but it becomes almost useless if the customer service is horrible. It was critical that the companies had convenient and accessible service, with bonus points for those who had mobile apps and round-the-clock service.


We've researched and compared the renters insurance quotes and averages in cities such as Philadelphia, Pittsburgh, Allentown, Erie, Reading, and more.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much is renters insurance in PA?

The average cost of renters insurance in PA is $15 per month, or $180 per year. This compares to the typical yearly price tag of about 187 dollars for most Americans; however Liberty Mutual sells policies at a cheaper rate- only 11 bucks each month.

Do you need renters insurance in Pennsylvania?

You live in Pennsylvania, where renters insurance is not required by law. So while your landlord's insurance might cover things like damage to common areas of the property or other people living on site and their belongings, it won't protect you from theft (and if someone gets hurt inside your unit they may sue). That means that as a renter here you need coverage for personal injury protection too! You're lucky because NJM Renters Insurance has policies with those covers already included at affordable rates.

How fast can you get renters insurance?

Renters insurance can be obtained in a matter of minutes with the right company. With just 5-10 minutes, you could have renters coverage for your personal items and liability protection from accidents that occur at home. Unlike homeowners insurance, it's not time consuming to fill out forms or go through an agent as there are no property exclusions such as earthquake damage, floods and surface water seepage among others.